Whether one supports the war in Iraq or is against it,

everyone says they support our troops and proceeds to

criticize or demonize those who don’t believe as they

  1. There are passionate human beings on both sides of

the political spectrum.

 

On June 21, USA Today editorialized, “there is no

choice but to stay the course” in Iraq. “Cutting and

running would cauterize the losses, but the

longer-term risks are alarming: of Iraq becoming a

terrorist refuge; of full-scale civil war; of hopes

for democracy crumbling in Iraq and the region.” The

editorial suggested that to recalibrate in Iraq, three

issues must be confronted: The U.S. troop level in

Iraq where troops have been stretched thin; the time

needed for Iraqis to be able to take over defending

their country, since a “minimum competence” could take

two years or more; and the maintenance of American

public support as Americans need to know “what

success” is supposed to be.

 

On June 22, the secretary-general of the United

Nations and a representative international group vowed

at a conference in Brussels, sponsored by the United

States and Europe, “By our words and more importantly

by our deeds we must reassure (the people of Iraq)

that we will not let them down.” Yet, Americans now

say the war was not “worth it.”

 

A senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for

International Peace, Robert Kagan, wrote “Whether This

War Was Worth It” in the June 19 Washington Post,

asserting that “there is nothing remarkable about

polls showing Americans wondering whether the recent

Iraq war was ‘worth it’.” Kagan says it was “a great

American myth” voiced by John Kerry last year that

America goes to war only when there is no question

about the necessity of going to war. “There’s always a

question,” Kagan lamented.

 

He argues that even if the Iraqi insurgency would

disappear tomorrow, “George Ibrahim al Washington”

became president, and Saddam Hussein’s onetime

chemical and biological weapons stockpile suddenly

appeared in the desert, “historians would still spend

the next century debating whether the war was ‘worth

it.'”

 

“No war has produced unmitigated successes,” Kagan

reminds: African-Americans remained oppressed a

century after the Civil War; World War I destroyed

Europe and helped the rise of Hitler and the Soviet

Union; World War II defeated Hitler but enslaved half

of Europe behind the Iron Curtain and introduced

nuclear weapons; the Persian Gulf War drove Hussein

out of Kuwait but helped produce Osama bin Laden.

 

“Demanding unmixed results and guarantees against the

unintended consequences of war is as unrealistic as

demanding absolute confidence in the ‘necessity’ of

going to war in the first place,” Kagan argues.

 

The problem, he says, is that we always know what did

happen as a result of war, but we “never know what

didn’t happen,” — we can only guess what might have

happened if Hitler was allowed to conquer Europe, or

communist victories in Korea and Vietnam went

unchallenged.

 

What may have happened if the Bush administration had

not gone to war in Iraq? Considering the kind of

leader Saddam Hussein was, would a decision not to go

to war have produced a lasting peace, or would it only

have delayed war until a later date, as happened in

the 1930s? Kagan pointed to the “well-documented,

unrefuted — and unnoticed — conclusion” of both

weapons inspectors David Kay and Charles Duelfer that

Hussein remained committed to acquiring weapons of

mass destruction, and whether he would have eventually

succeeded would have depended on the world’s will and

ability to stop him.

 

“That is a question to which we will never have a

definitive answer, and yet it is critical to any

judgment about the merits of the war,” Kagan wrote. He

quoted former President Clinton’s national security

adviser, Samuel “Sandy” Berger, that containment of

Saddam Hussein was not “sustainable over the long

run.”

 

Nevertheless, Kagan says, the Bush administration is

not absolved from the “errors that it made before and

after the war and continues to make today.” These are

the kinds of consideration that ought to be part of

any serious debate over whether the war in Iraq was

“worth it,” argues Kagan.

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the

University of Guam, where he taught political science

for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

 

Originally published July 6, 2005