The United States’ “guest-worker program” limits the
issuance of H visas to 65,000 highly skilled
professionals a year in specialty occupations, such as
the physical sciences, engineering or mathematics.
Visa holders may stay in the United States for a
maximum of six years. The professionals are H-1B visa
holders. Their spouses and children, under 21, can
enter the United States under H-4 visas.
The initial law authorized 195,000 skilled
professionals from abroad to take temporary jobs in
the United States between 2001 and 2003.
On Oct. 3, in “Immigrant Wives’ Visa Status Keeps Them
Out of Workplace,” the Washington Post reported that
the high-tech industry’s successful lobbying in
Congress saw “hundreds of thousands of guest workers,”
mostly young men from India and China, land on U.S.
soil. Figures from the State Department showed nearly
half a million H-1B visas were issued in the past four
years, while about 300,000 H-4 visas were issued to
their dependents.
While spouses of diplomats and business executives can
legally work in the United States, spouses of H-1B
visa holders cannot.
And thus, Hanuma Samavedam, a native of India, with an
MBA degree and a background as a finance manager at an
Indian accounting firm, was left to watch her
“academic medals and trophies” in a crowded U.S.
apartment as her “career vegetated for four years.”
Brazilian native Marselha Goncalves, with a master’s
degree in international peace and conflict resolution
from American University, wife of a Frenchman on an
H-1B visa, had to split from him to work in Haiti.
Bindu Reddy, a former special-education teacher from
India, volunteered at school, browsed job listings on
the Internet — although no place would hire her —
and waits for her husband to get a green card so that
she can “have choices again.”
Immigration lawyer Elizabeth Espin Stern of Baker &
McKenzie LLP sees the situation of neglect for spouses
and families, as “an arrogant stance” and
“insensitive.”
Lawyer and immigrant advocate Shivali Shah, co-founder
of a South Asian women’s organization in North
Carolina, Kiran, who teaches at Rutgers, was quoted by
the Post: “The H-4 visa is taking some of the
brightest women in India and turning them into
housewives here. … Their lives as professionals
would have thrived in India but here, they are just
somebody’s wife.”
Shah lamented that the H-4 dependent women have few
advocates. Immigration lawyers represent employers or
workers; other organizations tend to rally behind
“poor, undocumented migrants.”
According to the Sept. 27 USA Today, although the
total number of immigrants entering the U.S. each year
— legally and illegally — has declined, the number
of illegal immigrants to the country has increased.
The Post reported that advocates of more restrictive
immigration laws say allowing H-4 dependents to work
would take away jobs from Americans. Christopher
Bently of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration
Services expressed empathy with the dependents but
said these dependents knew before entering the United
States that their status would be temporary and
dependent.
“It’s a choice they made,” Bentley said.
A former University of Guam professor, now an
administrator at Virginia Tech, who is a subscriber to
the e-mail Immigration Daily — “the news source for
legal professionals” — told me that most of Virginia
Tech’s H-1B faculty and staff are from India and the
People’s Republic of China, and that their H-4 wives
cannot work. The professor sent me a story of Mona,
26, a bachelor’s degree holder in electrical and
electronic engineering from Bangalore, who left her
career to join her husband in the United States and
cannot work.
To work legally, an H-4 spouse needs to find an
employer willing and able to sponsor her H-1B visa; or
wait for her husband’s employer to sponsor him for a
green card, a long process.
The agency charged in admitting immigrants to the
United States, the CIS, “is in disarray,” reported the
Oct. 3 Washington Times; its employees face “thousands
of charges,” the CIS faces “a backlog of applications
for green cards” and it simply cannot “take on” the
countless new cases under the guest-worker program, as
President George W. Bush wanted.
And so, qualifications notwithstanding, an H-4 spouse
is just “somebody’s wife.” As Shah described, these
dependents lose productive years as they wait for
their spouses to come home to take them to the grocery
store.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published October 26, 2005