Mumbai-born U.S. citizen Fareed Zakaria is a Muslim
and resident of New York City. He holds a bachelor’s
degree from Yale and a doctorate in political science
from Harvard. He was named by Esquire magazine as “one
of the 21 most important people of the 21st Century”
and has been editor of Newsweek International since
October 2000. He writes for the domestic edition of
Newsweek magazine, and his writings also have appeared
in major U.S. newspapers, including the Washington
Post, the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal.
In “After America’s Eclipse” in the Jan. 29 Washington
Post (the same article, titled “Preview of a Post-U.S.
World,” is in the Feb. 5 Newsweek), Zakaria noted an
absence of the customary “America-bashing” in Davos,
Switzerland, where 2,400 participants from 90
countries met from Jan. 24-28 at an annual gathering
of the World Economic Forum under the theme “Shaping
the Global Agenda: The Shifting Power Equation.”
He wrote, “For the first time I can remember, America
was somewhat peripheral” … there were “few demands,
complaints or tantrums” directed at America; and
people seemed to be “moving beyond America” and
“beyond George W. Bush.” He noted how WEF speakers
referenced the rise of Asia (China and India with a
combined population of 2.4 billion people in a world
of about 6.5 billion) and the implicit decline of the
United States and Europe.
Zakaria noted that German Chancellor Angela Merkel
called on everyone to be “flexible” at a new round of
trade talks; observed Washington’s exhibition of
“considerable flexibility” on contentious issues,
including agricultural subsidies, while Paris,
“eloquent critic of U.S. unilateralism,” refused to
budge on its “lavish subsidies for farmers.”
Zakaria thinks in three years China will probably be
“the world’s biggest emitter of carbon dioxide.” He
quoted China’s representative, Zhu Min, on China’s
leadership in global environmental issues: “The ball
is not in China’s court,” while Indian planning czar
Montek Singh Ahluwalia retorted, “The ball is in
everybody’s court” and that “every country should have
the same per capita rights to pollution.”
Zakaria, who thinks if China and India “pollute at
average Western levels, you will have a global
meltdown,” concluded, “The ball for every problem is
in everybody’s court, which means that it is in
nobody’s court.”
“This free ride can’t last,” Zakaria argued, “The
global system — economic, political, social — is not
self-managing.” He posited that a world without
America — Bush being a lame duck, the United States
mired in Iraq and “hostility” toward Washington “still
high almost everywhere” — may be one devoid of
American “domination” and “leadership,” but this world
may likely be “a world in which problems fester and
the buck is endlessly passed until situations
explode.”
Saying this cannot make him popular, but I find a ring
of truth to what he contends.
I logged on to the WEF Web site, and dusted off from
my bookshelves British historian Niall Ferguson’s
article, “A World Without Power” in the July-Aug. 2004
Foreign Policy magazine.
A Harvard University professor, Ferguson is a senior
research fellow at Oxford University, a senior fellow
at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, a
prolific writer in the British and American press, and
a regular contributor to American and British
television and radio. In 2004, Time magazine named him
“one of the world’s hundred most influential people.”
He and his family divide their time living in America
and England.
Ferguson sees “the struggle for mastery” as perennial
and universal. In his provocative 2004 Foreign Policy
article, he argued that the retreat of the United
States from its hegemonic role is likely to leave a
“power vacuum” as Europe, China, the Muslim world and
certainly not the United Nations can step in to
replace it.
Referring to a world without a hegemon, Ferguson
wrote, “Apolarity could turn out to mean an anarchic
new Dark Age: an era of waning empires and religious
fanaticism; of endemic plunder and pillage in the
world’s forgotten regions; of economic stagnation and
civilization’s retreat into a few fortified enclaves.”
Ferguson warned of a “global vacuum of power” when
America is eclipsed, and that “far more dangerous
forces than rival great powers would benefit from such
a not-so-new world disorder.”
Zakaria thought that Ferguson’s vision “might be a
little farfetched,” but didn’t brush off Ferguson’s
warning to “those waiting for the waning of American
dominance” — “Be careful what you wish for.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 7, 2007