Several dozen readers sent comments on my last article “No Liberal Government As Long As Hun Sen Lives” (Oct. 4).  I found the variety of reactions informative.  There was a distinctive theme to views expressed by Khmers that differed from thoughts shared by non-Khmer.  The contrast aligns with my frequent advocacy of the contention that how we think is more important than what we know.

I believe that Hun Sen, who is a cunning and cagy survivor, probably understands that he would benefit if he were to voluntarily step down from power.  His removal from office is an eventual inevitability.  Better for him and for his country if he initiates the act of departure than waits to be removed by the ballot box or by force.  Unfortunately, his ego and his narcissism evoke his feelings of invincibility

Nevertheless, I also believe that a series of events, actions, and circumstances could converge to precipitate a tipping point.  If the right spots are pushed at the right time, what seems like an unchangeable situation can be altered.  As Lord Buddha has taught us, “Nothing is permanent.”

Cambodia’s current political environment is not conducive to free and fair elections. Hun Sen realizes that in free and fair elections he and his ruling Cambodian People’s Party are very unlikely to stay in power. Thus, he will do anything to keep the opposition party, the CNRP, from succeeding to power.

On Oct. 19, United Nations human rights rapporteur Rhona Smith told a Phnom Penh press conference that “Human rights are not a threat to national security and human rights monitoring does not threaten sovereignty”; that the time to “blame the troubles of the last century for the situation today is surely over.” She said, “I am saddened by the deterioration in the political situation since my mission in March.”

During Smith’s current mission the government rejected a request from the CNRP to stage a rally at Freedom Park to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Paris Peace Agreements; rejected CNRP leader Sam Rainsy’s offer to go to jail in exchange for the release of 19 CNRP figures currently imprisoned.  Further, Hun Sen’s court wants Bou Rachana, wife of slain political analyst Kem Ley, to appear in Phnom Penh to be questioned.  She and her five children have fled Cambodia and are awaiting political asylum.  Additionally, Hun Sen’s Interior Ministry slapped Rainsy with a new legal complaint that he had incited “mass demonstrations like 2013 and early 2014” against the government when he spoke to youth activists in Phnom Penh via videolink from Paris.

The non-profit World Justice Project issued its annual Rule of Law Index ranking Cambodia 112th of 113 countries surveyed globally, and last in the East Asia and Pacific region based on rule of law. It follows that the forthcoming elections will appear to sanction continued rule by Hun Sen and the CPP; and guarantee a replay of Cambodia’s political crisis as occurred after the 2013 elections.   Khmer democrats will cry foul and the CNRP will be pressured by the world community to accept Hun Sen’s victory.  The political circle dance – Ramvong – will continue.

In reality, overwhelming numbers of Khmers in the country and abroad want change after 31 years of CPP government that is focused on enhancing the power and wealth of its leaders at the expense of the common good.   The question is how to accomplish this necessary change.

More than one way to skin a cat:  There are hopeful signs of support for the end to autocracy in Cambodia.  As I described earlier this month, US House Resolution 728 – supporting human rights, democracy, and the rule of law in Cambodia – has bipartisan sponsorship from 21 members of the US Congress.  US Senate bill S 284, which would authorize sanctions with respect to foreign persons responsible for gross violations of internationally recognized human rights, and for other purposes, has passed the Senate and awaits action in the US House of Representatives.  Khmer democrats should actively support both measures.

In September, the International Criminal Court (ICC) announced a new policy that authorizes prosecution of crimes related to “destruction of the environment”, “exploitation of natural resources,” the “illegal dispossession” of land.   On Oct. 19, Global Diligence lawyer Richard J. Rogers wrote in Open Democracy to describe the ICC’s new prioritization of crimes involving environmental destruction and land grabbing. Rogers’ ICC filing has cracked the door open for prosecution of Hun Sen and his ruling elite: Some 850,000 Cambodian people are affected by land conflicts; 300-400,000 have been evicted from their land; about 145,000 Phnom Penh residents have been displaced, some “killed, raped, brutally beaten, and imprisoned on false charges.” Can there be a small encampment near The Hague with a Khmer flag and signs protesting environment destruction, logging, land-grabbing by Cambodia’s Hun Sen regime?

Some Khmer readers’ reactions: Only two Khmer readers who wrote to me recently have acknowledged Bill S. 284 or the new ICC policy?  One was a senior member of the self-proclaimed “Patriotic Sons of the Khmer Republic”  https://www.facebook.com/100003019954736/videos/998132213630768/ called Khmer M’Chas Srok [Khmer Masters of the Land], who confessed his dismay “I didn’t know about Bill S. 284,” and he promised, “I’ll follow up on it.”  Another, a former officer of the Khmer People’s National Liberation Armed Forces, e-mailed from Phnom Penh expressing pleasure to learn about Bill S. 284 which he hoped would pass the House soon. He claimed 85% of Khmer youth do not support Prime Minister Hun Sen, and that many Khmers never voted for Hun Sen in 2013, “and yet he said he won.”

While most Khmer readers’ e-mails were short (“really like what you wrote”), some expressed a strong desire for change. A senior CNRP figure in Cambodia wrote: “Let me tell you one thing: Khmer people, and particularly CNRP militants are now standing up against attempt to derail our roadmap to a lasting democracy. . . People want change. At all cost.” His words gave me goose bumps. From Australia, a Khmer elder wrote: “A dictator like him [Hun Sen] should have been eliminated long ago by real patriots.” The elder who pleaded, “We should not underestimate Sam Rainsy,” brought up a Khmer traditional prediction Puth Tum Neay about an emerging Neak Mien Bon or one with great merit, but expressed anxiety over the prediction of Chhiem Dap Poh Damrei or “blood stained the elephant stomach,” caused by many deaths.

On the other hand, some Khmer readers who referenced my article posted their comments on the Internet for public consumption.  One writer whose comments appeared regularly on Internet, counselled Khmer to “change their mindset” (though she never said what “mindset”).  In her view, Cambodia can be liberated by the “right leaders with high moral standard, not involved in “scandal” [like Kem Sokha?] nor “running away all the time” [like Sam Rainsy?], nor in corruption.” She asked rhetorically “Should others stand up and lift the CNRP flag and move on?” A few Khmer writers weighed in to share her view, denouncing CNRP leaders. Ah, Hun Sen and the CPP must be pleased.

I am not a fan of Sam Rainsy or Kem Sokha. But I am reminded of a Native American saying, “Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his moccasins.” Despite flaws, the CNRP represents the main opposition to Hun Sen and the CPP. Smaller political parties play into Hun Sen’s desire to divide the opposition to maximize the CPP’s opportunity to return to power. My vote goes to Rainsy and Sokha.

Recall French philosopher Michel de Montaigne’s “There is no man so good that if he placed all his actions and thought under the scrutiny of the laws, he would not deserve hanging ten times in his life.”

From correspondence I have received and observed in public postings, Khmer still revere Dr. Kem Ley, who was slain in July. One writer asked, “How many Khmer leaders can do like him [Kem Ley]? I don’t see one yet…” A few days ago, Radio Free Asia’s “Kem Ley’s Spirit Still Powerful in Cambodia,” broadcast a moving 100-day ritual ceremony of Kem Ley.  Unbeknown to many, Dr. Kem Ley, his wife Bou Rachana, and some leading figures of grassroots advocacy Khmer for Khmer (K4K) – precursor to the Grassroots Democracy Party (GDP) – met with some Khmer M’Chas Srok leaders including Dr. Chak Sakhonn to discuss Cambodia’s future sans Hun Sen.

An e-mail from a Khmer democrat demanded a “written, thoroughly debated, member(s) approved concession” from the CPP, and advised, the “CNRP must not rejoin the National Assembly,” as it would give the ruling CPP legitimacy to sign border agreements with Vietnam. But what would the CNRP be if it abdicated its elected role in the state institution?

And there was an e-mail from someone who thanked me for articles I wrote. He told me, the “Vietnamese are enjoying full rights to come and go [in Cambodia] as they please. And Khmer citizens are suffering. . .” He said “The world is much to blame,” and called on “our Khmer people [to] rise up altogether to defend their ballots” in the 2017-2018 elections. He wrote, a “[r]eal chance for change in Cambodia [can occur] only when blood will be shed on the country’s streets and lives will be lost.” In a separate e-mail, he provided a list of what Sam Rainsy, Kem Sokha, and CNRP-World Supporters, “MUST DO” [sic.]. I recalled the words of US President Theodore Roosevelt about the difference between the “critic” and “the man who is actually in the arena.”

Some non-Khmer readers’ reaction: A retired professor wrote, “Yes, don’t expect any change until Hun Sen departs the planet, either thru natural causes or otherwise!” A retired bureaucrat sent came a comment and a question, “I know that Cambodians are non-violent people, normally, but couldn’t a bad accident befall Hun Sen?” Whoa! I am reminded of what I used to encourage my students of politics to learn to set goals that are Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, and Time-bound (S.M.A.R.T.).

But it was an e-mail from a non-Khmer academic that made a great impression on me: “No war-weary soldiers of past battles can save the Khmer people from Hun Sen’s oppression. Neither, of course, can other governments around the world, torn between altruism and democratic hopes, on the one hand, and the tantalizing possibilities for trade and enrichment.” The academic touched on what has pricked my brain for some time: “It is time for a new generation to pick up the shield and sword. To define the country in their own terms. There are already many brave, young individuals that represent the very best ideals, fighting for the rule of law and human rights in Cambodia.”

“Of course, this new generation would be wise to learn from the history imparted by elders. But they alone must carry the flag of freedom.” “It seems that democracy can only be achieved by asserting the collective will of the people. It cannot be realized by the flowery speeches of a single man. It must exist in the hearts of ‘the many’, in the hearts of ordinary citizens. Collective courage will bring liberation from the chains of tyranny.” “People must personally feel the desire for change and determine for themselves what they can do about it. Out of this individual introspection and resolve my come a swelling wave of collective action.”

Amen!