Should Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice have her
way, there would be a cease-fire to end
Israel-Hezbollah hostilities by the time you read this
column.
But her boss, President George W. Bush, has rejected
“stopping (hostilities) for the sake of stopping.”
Israeli Premier Ehud Olmert wants more time to pound
on Hezbollah, and establish a multinational force as a
buffer between Israel and Lebanon to precede a
cease-fire. Hezbollah says all Israeli troops must
leave Lebanon and Iranian President Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad wants “the elimination of the Zionist
regime.”
In the July 28 New York Times news analysis, “2 Steps
Back: Rice’s Careful Diplomacy Falters Under Renewed
Assertiveness by the U.S.,” Rice’s “public relations
war” was seen as lost as reports from Rome “uniformly”
painted her as unyielding to “impassioned calls for an
immediate cease-fire.”
The Times acknowledged: “In reality, while many
diplomats have called for an immediate cease-fire,
they support the American package as the only way to
cobble together a peace plan that shores up the
government of Lebanon and leads to the disarmament of
Hezbollah.”
There was already an agreement, wrote the Times, among
world leaders in Rome “on the framework” of a
“cease-fire package” to emerge from the U.N. Security
Council.
France, currently president of the Security Council,
on July 31 was floating an international plan that
would position a multinational force as a buffer
between Lebanon and Israel, but after a cease-fire is
put in place — inconsistent with Israel’s position.
As world diplomats, including those from the United
States, discussed a cease-fire package at U.N.
headquarters in New York, ground realities in the
Middle East found Israel and Hezbollah locked in
battle, with an uncertain outcome.
No capitulation
Hezbollah’s raison d’etre is to destroy the Jewish
state. Hezbollah has shown what no Arab state has
until now: It has not capitulated to Israeli military
might. Her reputation for invincibility has helped to
shield Israel from her many enemies in the Arab world.
The Aug. 1 Christian Science Monitor quoted Brookings
Institution’s Middle East policy expert, Michael
O’Hanlon: “It’s a moment for strong American
leadership” and for “international determination to
impose conditions” to end hostilities. To O’Hanlon,
the Bush administration now sees that “this crisis is
just too tragic to be allowed to spin further out of
control,” and the Monitor noted observers as seeing
the administration learning a lesson that “a
stand-alone position was not working in quelling an
international crisis.”
In the Aug. 1 editorial, “A Solution for Lebanon:
Behind all the rhetoric, there’s a consensus that
Hezbollah must be weakened and contained,” the
Washington Post said the United States, Israel and the
Lebanese government seek “the same outcome” to the
fighting — disarming Hezbollah, deploying Lebanon’s
army in the south and extending Lebanon’s
“sovereignty” over the entire country.
“Despite all the rhetoric about an immediate
cease-fire and the predictable focus by media outlets
around the world on Israel’s mistakes and excesses,”
the Post editorialized, “every party in the Middle
East other than Hezbollah and its Syrian and Iranian
sponsors believes that a resolution to the crisis that
fails to achieve those conditions would be a
catastrophe.”
Even Lebanese Druze leader Walid Jumblatt, “who is no
friend of the United States or Israel,” told the Post:
“Either we will have a state able to establish its
control over the country or we will have … a reduced
weakened state and a strong militia beside the
Lebanese army that decides war and peace at any time
and has its schedule decided by the Iranians and the
Syrians.”
‘Consistent message’
So there is a “quiet consensus,” and “all sides” know
that Hezbollah, which “represents many Lebanese
Shiites, cannot be destroyed or entirely disarmed by
military means,” said the Post. “But it can, and must,
be weakened, forced to retreat and deprived of the
ability to attack across the international border at
will.”
The Post sees “any Israeli stand-down” as dependent on
European governments and Security Council members’
readiness to “authorize and supply” an international
force with “sufficient strength and authority to deter
Hezbollah.”
And the Post urges a “consistent message” from the
world community to Iran and Syria: “to cooperate in
stabilizing the Middle East … will ease their
isolation. But attempts to acquire weapons of mass
destruction or wage proxy war through groups such as
Hezbollah will be answered with strength, not
appeasement.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 9, 2006