Hurricane Katrina, with 160-mph winds, decimated New
Orleans. It littered the city with the dead and all
manner of toxins, creating the danger of disease
outbreaks. Families have been uprooted, split and
scattered; 400,000 jobs are expected to be lost. The
scene is reminiscent of a Third-World drama. But this
is America.
Debate on the storm and its aftermath shall continue
for a long time. Yet the storm was predicted and a
powerful storm over New Orleans was listed as one of
the most catastrophic events that could befall
America. The sinking land, the rising sea levels, the
disappearance of the wetlands and barrier islands, the
levees that can break — all of this was well known.
If the different levels of government failed to deal
with what was known and foreseen, how would a surprise
biological, chemical or nuclear attack be dealt with?
On. Aug. 24, with Katrina over the Bahamas, it was
warned that the storm could cross Florida and
“re-intensify” over the Gulf of Mexico. It did. On
Aug. 25, with 80-mph winds, Katrina struck Florida; it
grew a day later to Category 2, with 100-mph winds,
and headed toward Louisiana. Roads out of the Gulf
Coast were clogged with miles of vehicles fleeing
danger.
On Aug. 27, Katrina, with 115-mph winds, was predicted
to make landfall in Louisiana. A New Orleans state of
emergency called on residents in low-lying areas (who
would not, or had no means to, leave) to evacuate
(How?). As Katrina grew to a Category 5 hurricane on
Aug. 28, residents were told to go to the Superdome.
President George W. Bush declared Louisiana and
Mississippi disaster areas on Aug. 29. That night, two
levees broke in New Orleans. On Aug. 30, 80 percent of
the city was under water, with some areas beneath 20
feet of fetid water. Looting and lawlessness reigned;
an estimated 100,000 people still remained in the
city. The president said he would shorten his vacation
to return to Washington; Katrina and its aftermath
were dubbed an “incident of national significance.”
The president flew over the region on his way back to
Washington on Aug. 31, as people struggled below. On
Sept. 1, Mayor Nagin issued “a desperate SOS.” Bush
visited the Gulf Coast on Sept. 2 and admitted the
results of government relief efforts were “not
acceptable.” National Guard troops arrived in New
Orleans that day.
Federal, state and local officials and partisans
busily point fingers at one another.
The Sept. 5 Washington Post editorial, “Unprepared,”
speaks of the “infuriating, unmistakable and unnerving
lesson” that lies in “the fundamental failure of
government at all levels to protect its citizens.” On
its front page, the Sept. 9 Post said five of eight
top FEMA officials had “virtually no experience in
handling disasters.” Two days earlier, Post reporters
referred to FEMA director Michael D. Brown as “the
accidental director, … caricatured as the failed
head of an Arabian horse sporting group, … plucked
from obscurity” to be Bush’s “point man for the worst
natural disaster in U.S. history.”
On Sept. 4, Louisiana’s Times-Picayune’s open letter
to Bush called for every FEMA official to be fired,
“Director Michael Brown especially.” The White House,
Laura and Barbara Bush defended the president and Bush
praised Brown: “Brownie, you’re doing a heck of a
job,” he said. But critics are not all Democrats or
liberals.
Well-known conservative columnist Charles
Krauthammer’s “Where to Point the Fingers,” in the
Sept. 9 Washington Post, blasted Brown as “late, slow
and in way over his head,” Bush as “late, slow, and
simply out of tune with the urgency and magnitude of
the disaster” and the Congress as “now as always
playing holier than thou.”
The Post quoted Iraq War-supporter William Kristol,
editor of the Weekly Standard: “Almost every
Republican I have spoken with is disappointed” in
Bush’s handling of the disaster. “He is a strong
president, … but he has never really focused on the
importance of good execution. I think that is true in
many parts of his presidency.”
Conservative Washington Times editor Tony Blankley’s
“Complacency and Survival” of Sept. 7, laid “the
responsibility for the calamity” on Bush, state and
local officials, bureaucrats and individual citizens,
among others, as causing the death of thousands of
Americans.
What do we on Guam learn from the lessons of Katrina?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published September 14, 2005