University of Virginia psychology professor Timothy D.
Wilson, author of “Strangers to Ourselves: Discovering
the Adaptive Unconscious,” wrote “Don’t Think Twice,
It’s All Right” in the Dec. 29, 2005, New York Times.
In it, he described that end-of-the-year time when we
take stock of what has just passed: “navel gazing time
again,” as many men and women look inside to see what
may have gone wrong that could be changed to improve
their lives.
Wilson asked, “Does it really do any good?” and agreed
with poet Theodore Roethke’s insight that
“Self-contemplation is a curse/That makes an old
confusion worse.”
ADVERTISEMENT
During more than a decade teaching at the University
of Guam, I counseled scores of students who struggled
for solutions to daily problems. Some life events have
long-term effects, as we all know.
Indeed, personal and national experiences and the
values and beliefs we learn from family, school and
society shape and mold us. But are we really stuck in
a groove? Can good or bad karma overwhelm us
indefinitely? Do we not possess some free will to
change what we don’t like, following the concepts of
“humans propose, god dispose?”
Surely there are things that cannot be changed. I was
born a brown man and will live as a brown man until
death, no matter where I live. I can move to a
different place, and though I may not change how
others see me, I am in control of how I see them. In
the “Serenity Prayer,” I seek the serenity to accept
what cannot be changed, the courage to change what can
be, and the wisdom to know the difference.
In a study Wilson did with colleagues from the
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and
Moravian College in Pennsylvania, a group of people
was asked to list reasons and to rate how satisfied
each was in a romantic relationship. Members of
another group were asked to give their “gut feelings”
and to rate their satisfaction with a relationship,
“without any analysis.” Study outcomes found that
those who assessed relationships based on their “gut
feelings” were more accurate than “navel gazers” in
predicting the status of their relationships.
The scholars concluded that there are “severe limits”
to discovery through “self-reflection” and that “too
much analysis can confuse people about how they really
feel.”
Wilson cited a Yale University clinical psychologist’s
research that shows that self-reflection is a problem
when one is feeling down. In Wilson’s words, “when
people are depressed, ruminating on their problems
makes things worse.”
Wilson wrote that when some “mildly depressed” college
students were asked to spend eight minutes thinking
about themselves, or thinking about “mundane topics”
like cloud formation in the sky, students in the first
group focused on the negatives in their lives and
“sunk into a worse mood,” while those thinking about
clouds “actually felt better afterward,” as they never
focused on their negative selves.
Interestingly, a team led by a Harvard clinical
psychologist concluded that “debriefing procedures”
that focused on emergency workers’ 9-11 experiences in
order to help them “move past” them, to “feel better”
and to prevent mental-health problems down the road
were found to have “little benefit and might even hurt
by interrupting the normal healing process.” Removing
oneself from painful events right after they occur
“may be better than mentally reliving the events,”
wrote Wilson.
So perhaps the best course, Wilson hypothesizes, is to
think positive thoughts, do positive things, and be
happy with aspects of life that have satisfied us, and
for us to “act more like the person we want to be,
rather than sitting around analyzing ourselves.” He
said that many social-psychological studies have
“confirmed” Aristotle’s observation: “We become just
by the practice of just actions, self-controlled by
exercising self-control, and courageous by performing
acts of courage.”
Wilson pointed to University of Kansas social
psychologists who found that people given a chance to
do a favor for others ended up viewing themselves as
kind and considerate — “unless, that is, they were
asked to reflect on why they had done the favor,” and
then this latter group began not to view themselves as
especially kind.
As we are beginning the New Year 2006, we should move
beyond past regrets and toward making the tomorrows
better for ourselves and those all around.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published January 25, 2006