I’m glad we live in a land where the right to disagree
and the civil exercise of disagreement through
discussion and debate are regarded as healthy and
protected freedoms. These provide a broader
perspective and encourage a more open-minded
citizenry.
“Finding ways to talk, listening carefully to the
other’s views, and finding common ground take hard
work,” read an editorial of the Christian Science
Monitor during the last presidential campaign. “Half
the battle is willingness to accept that the other
guy’s motives are good.” America’s forefather, James
Madison, said, “men are not angels.”
Today, an informal, man-on-the-street survey affirmed
a common view — that civility has broken down in
contemporary urban society. It seems more of us are
not able to disagree without being disagreeable. On a
larger scale, these disagreements become the source of
serious political conflict.
At the University of Guam, I led students to discuss
the meaning and the consequences of Guam as a
territory ceded to the United States by the 1898
Spanish-American Treaty of Peace, and the U.S.
Congress’ 1950 Organic Act that made the island an
“unincorporated territory” of the United States.
Can we have it both ways? Can Guam be part and parcel
of the United States and yet be an “unincorporated”
territory?
The people of Guam are U.S. citizens, and yet the
Organic Act applies to them only the “second sentence
of section 1” of the 14th amendment of the U.S.
Constitution, while the non-applicable first sentence
reads, “All persons born or naturalized in the United
States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are
citizens of the United States and of the State wherein
they reside.”
The people of Guam, who are U.S. citizens, cannot vote
for the president of the United States.
Rodriguez v. Gaylord established that because Guam is
an unincorporated territory, its government “has only
those powers conferred upon it by Congress.”
The political status of Guam is a highly emotionally
charged issue for many island people. Some of Guam’s
leaders are on record saying that a document adopted
can be changed.
Changed to what?
The people of Guam are divided among those who want
self-determination — full incorporation with the
United States (statehood); semi-independence (freely
associated states); independence; and those who prefer
the status quo.
In spite of endless discussions on the island’s
political status, including the need for a plebiscite,
the island continues to function and be administered
in the same old ways. And yet a constant in life is
change. Joe Murphy’s “Economic shakeup inevitable as
relocation of Marines draws near,” in the Nov. 6
Pacific Daily News, presents a position worth
considering.
More than a half century has passed since the Organic
Act came into existence. As the world advances,
debates continue on an island of unique beauty and
charm, whose population is unquestionably hospitable
and welcoming. And so in my column last week, I
suggested a number of things to do, instead of waiting
for independence or statehood, that appear unlikely.
Changes brought about by globalization cannot be
stopped. Globalization knows no border, no culture, no
ethnicity. Still, the old traditional ways need not be
lost as we provide our children with the educational
tools to function in the 21st century.
My 7-year-old grandson, born and raised in America,
has yet to visit Asia and yet already clasps his
hands, bows his head with grace and has greeted my
sisters in my native tongue, and wielded chopsticks to
eat the noodle soup they prepared. He and his baby
sister have learned a number of folk stories from my
native land that my wife and I adapted into English
for them.
Life evolves. Change continues. Slowly, gradually and
naturally, we will evolve. People of my age will not
witness important future changes; those of my former
students’ age may; and their children and my
grandchildren will work to improve what we have left
for them — or discard tools and ideas that become
obsolete.
There are things that are not right, just or fair in
our world. It may be hard to maintain optimism facing
them, but pessimism and despair are not the answer.
Whether or not we take action, events will occur
around us. But if we do something, we may find a more
satisfactory result.
As the saying goes: “If you do what you’ve always
done, you’ll always get what you’ve always got.”
I taught in school: A thesis yields anti-thesis and
synthesis. Nothing stands still.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published December 6, 2006