It’s fashionable these days to talk about the decline
of the United States, and the West, and the rise of
China and India, and the developing world. Arguments
and counter-arguments abound.
President George W. Bush has been blamed for anything
negative, domestically and internationally, yet
America’s decline in world standing has predated him,
according to some respected observers.
The 15th-18th Centuries marked the rise of the West.
It was at the end of that time period that America was
born. The United States rose to international
pre-eminence through the 20th century.
Thus, national security columnist for the liberal
Slate magazine, Fred Kaplan, writes in the Feb. 3 Los
Angeles Times “Downsizing our dominance,” that “Bush’s
follies” have accelerated America’s decline in world
influence, but that decline started, ironically, with
“the West’s victory” at the end of the Cold War
following the breakup of the Soviet Union.
“For half a century, we had been a super-power,” says
Kaplan. “Now we’re upper-middle management in a world
without bosses … the next (U.S.) president, and the
one after that … will have to get down in the dirt,
strike deals and trade favors … facing up to the
limits of (U.S.) power in a newly fractured world.”
Senior research fellow in the American strategy
program of the New America Foundation, Parag Khanna,
posits in the Jan. 27 New York Times’ “Waving Goodbye
to Hegemony,” that in the “new global order,” the
geopolitics of the 21st Century consists of “the new
Big Three” — the European Union within the West,
China in the East, and the U.S., isolated — with
“second-world countries” lying alongside and between
the Big Three.
They are “swing states” that “will determine which of
the superpowers has the upper hand for the next
generation of geopolitics.”
Khanna argues that “there is precious little Clinton
or McCain or Obama could do to resist” the growth of
this new order in which the U.S. is not “bestriding
the globe” but is “competing — and losing –in a
geopolitical marketplace.”
Khanna views “globalization” as having “brought about
the erosion of American primacy.” He sees the
second-world countries’ “first priority is not to
become America but to succeed by any means,” and
claims that their hero is Singapore’s Lee Kuan Yew.
“What we have today, for the first time in history,”
argues Khanna, “is a global, multicivilizational,
multipolar battle.”
In the March 31, New York Times’ “The Baton Passes to
Asia,” liberal commentator Roger Cohen writes from
Hong Kong that in Asia, home to one third of humanity,
“Chinese, Indian and Vietnamese domestic markets
explode. … There are 450 million cell phones in
China. … Some 300 million” Indians will be moving in
the next 20 years from rural to urban India, a country
that is likely to “overtake Japan as the world’s third
largest economy,” behind the U.S. and China.
Cohen is impressed with Hong Kong’s “efficiency and
high-speed airport train (that) makes New York seem
third-world,” with Hong Kong Secretary for Commerce
Frederick Ma, whose infrastructure plans are
“mind-boggling,” and who revealed when he visited the
U.S. a banker friend told him, “a Wall Street problem
was soon going to be a Main Street problem.” “I am
very worried about the U.S. economy,” Cohen said Ma
told him.
Cohen quoted prominent global strategist Claude
Smadja, who said the feeling in Asia is one of “a
burst of energy, of new dreams, and the end of the era
of Western domination and the white man.”
Last November, an old friend from another continent
e-mailed me Australia’s “On Line Opinion,” entitled,
“Socialism triumphant — only with Chinese
characteristics,” by Reg Little, a 25-year veteran of
Australia’s diplomatic service, and author of 2006 “A
Confucian-Daoist Millennium?” The article led me to
further research.
Little’s book examines 10 selected features of East
Asia — “distinctive practices of administration,
education, spirituality, consciousness, change
management, science, services, knowledge, health and
energy,” which he sees provide China with a socialism
as a “model that offers hope for people in diverse
parts of the world.”
“China’s vast population and productive capacity, the
length, depth and coherence of its cultural wisdom and
the astuteness of its administrative elite is
unmatched anywhere else,” contends Little.
He posits that the “Chinese, accompanied by Japanese,
Koreans and Vietnamese will lead the next millennium,”
and the 200-year “Anglo-American global order” has
seen “erosion” for the last several decades.
Scary thoughts about the future of the West’s global
order?
“Ignore the Obituaries, U.S. Reign Will Endure,” reads
a Feb. 4 Bloomberg.com’s column by the director of
economic policy studies at the conservative American
Enterprise Institute, Kevin Hassett, a Bloomberg News
columnist.
Bret Stephens’s “Marinating in ‘Decline'” in the Feb.
5 Wall Street Journal says McDonald’s — “the icon of
everything anti-Americans detest about the U.S.” — is
“doing a booming business overseas,” and Boeing is
“having no trouble booking orders.”
In the May-June issue of Foreign Affairs Magazine,
Fareed Zakaria, editor of Newsweek International that
runs eight editions in Asia, Latin America, Europe,
Australia and the Middle East, gives a balanced
examination of the question, “Is America in Decline?
Why the United States Will Survive the Rise of the
Rest.”
I shall take up this topic in my column next week.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.