Culture refers to the sum of attitudes (such as respect for elders and education), beliefs (in God, in karma, in hard work), and ways of doing things (smile gently and don’t laugh out loud, bow before the aged and don’t put feet on the table) that differentiate one group of people from another. In a world of political correctness, careless discussion of a people’s culture can win you the title of “bigot” or “racist.”

When my upper-level politics students at the University of Guam examined the book, “Culture Matters, How Values Shape Human Progress” (Basic Books, 2000), edited by Harvard University professors Lawrence E. Harrison and Samuel P. Huntington, many readily agreed with Huntington’s assertion that, “In short, cultures count.” But a few held on to the traditional explanations of “imperialism, dependency and racism” to show why some people are in worse situations than others.

David Brooks’ “All Cultures Are Not Equal,” in the Aug. 11 New York Times, argued that “while global economies are converging, cultures are diverging, and the widening cultural differences” have led us to a period of “conflict, inequality and segmentation.”

Globalization and a communications tech revolution were supposed to bring peoples together, he wrote, “But the opposite is true,” with “new groups and cultural zones” emerging.

In the Aug. 19 Washington Times’ “Success depends on (shhhh) culture,” Georgie Anne Geyer cited former Colorado governor and educator Richard Lamm, who offended the political sensibilities of many for years, and now will offend more. In Lamm’s “Two Wands, One Nation: An Essay on Race and Community in America,” in which black and Hispanic cultures are compared with Asian and Jewish cultures in their tendencies to foster ambition and success, Lamm wrote: “Different cultures give different signals, and some cultures are giving out stronger performance signals than others.”

In the May 14 New York Times’ “The Model Students,” Nicholas D. Kristof noted that “stellar academic achievement” in the United States increasingly “has an Asian face.” He cited statistics that show in 2005, Asian-Americans averaged a combined math-verbal SAT of 1091, compared with 1068 for whites, 982 for American Indians, 922 for Hispanics and 864 for blacks; and while two percent of whites scored 750 or better in either the math or verbal SAT, 3 percent of Asian-Americans beat 750 in verbal, and 8 percent beat 750 in math.

Kristof brushed aside the “brains, genetic selection” theory of Asians being “smarter” and posited that, “If I’m right, the success of Asian-Americans is mostly about culture.”

Kristof talked to Vietnamese Huan-Trang Ho, who spoke no English when she settled in Nebraska in 1994, at 11 years old. Both of her parents had no more than a high school education and worked as manual laborers. But Trang graduated as valedictorian from high school, and has a 3.99 grade point average as a senior at Nebraska Wesleyan. She is a Rhodes Scholar.

Trang could not speak for all Asian-Americans, she said, but “for me and my friends, it was because of the sacrifices that our parents made. … I see that there is so much I can do in America that my parents couldn’t.”

Kristof acknowledges that “teenagers rebel all over the world,” but 2,500 years of Confucianism’s “filial piety,” as Trang’s case suggests, and of Confucian teaching to revere education, have focused East Asian-American families “on their children’s getting ahead.” Asian-American kids “somehow” and “often manage both to exasperate and to finish their homework.”

Kristof wrote: “In a Confucian culture, it is intuitive that the way to achieve glory and success is by working hard and getting (the ‘A’).”

In Kristof’s analysis, American kids typically see those successful in school as the “brains” while East Asian kids typically say the “A” students are those who work hard, which “means no Asian-American ever has an excuse for not becoming valedictorian.” As he quoted Trang: “Anybody can be smart, can do great on standardized tests. But unless you work hard, you’re not going to do well.”

Whereas Kristof referenced “Asian-Americans” in general but spoke of Confucianism, a distinction should be clear between East Asian Confucian culture and the general Asian culture of acceptance, placidity, karma and suffering.

Indeed, culture matters.

Kristof thinks a culture can’t be transplanted. But he sees valuable lessons that can be learned. “The easiest” lesson to learn from East Asians is that “respect for education pays dividends.”

He counseled: “We would be fools not to try to learn some Asian lessons.”

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write to him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.

 

Originally published September 13, 2006