Ayub Nuri, a former Iraqi reporter who now studies at
Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism,
wrote in the Feb. 16 New York Times’ “My War Away From
War”: “Although I love my country, I needed to get
out.”
An editorial in the Feb. 12 Christian Science Monitor
says some 50,000 Iraqis a month are “fleeing sectarian
violence, targeted killings, and banditry”; up to 2
million Iraqis have left Iraq; and an estimated 1.8
million are displaced internally.
Nuri’s Iraq war is now oceans away, but “I had to
fight it every day.” Americans asked, “What went wrong
over there?” and “Do you think we should pull out?”
And Arabs and Muslims asked, “Who is behind these
killings?” and “most of them blamed America for
everything.”
Nuri said, “I agree that the American army is part of
the problem, but Iraqi militias are now responsible
for most of the killings.”
For Nuri, “No matter how I perceive the war, no matter
how many more friends I lose, no matter who is killing
whom, as long as there is a war, I have to live with
its nightmares and fight them thousands of miles
away.”
More than 3,000 American soldiers have died in the
Iraq war and many more have been hurt physically and
emotionally, some for life.
The Iraq war will find its closing chapter, like South
Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia did in 1975. American
troops in Iraq will come home, eventually.
New York lawyer Lynn Chu and law professor John Yoo of
the University of California at Berkely, argued in
their Feb. 12 New York Times column: “The fact is,
Congress has every power to end the war — if it
really wanted to. It has the power of the purse.”
Congress cut off funds for Vietnam in 1973 and the
Boland Amendment cut off money for the Nicaraguan
Contras in 1982.
“If Congress really believes the Bush administration
has set us on the wrong course, it can act tomorrow to
cut the sinews of war in Iraq,” Chu and Yoo
challenged.
Americans are polarized. Some can’t stand the sight or
the sound of President George W. Bush’s voice. But
anti-Iraq-war and anti-Bush rhetoric is met as
passionately by conservative writers and talk-show
hosts. Ross Douthat’s column in the March issue of
conservative Atlantic magazine, “Bush is fading. Bush
Republicanism is here to stay,” is worth reading.
Stanford’s Hoover Institution historian Victor Davis
Hanson wrote on Feb 22, in “Democrats disingenuous in
their anti-war rhetoric,” of ranking Democratic
senators who voted “to authorize a war with Iraq” on
Oct. 11, 2002, and asked, “Why is this war now
supposedly George Bush’s misfortune and not theirs?”
He reminds that the fear of Iraqi weapons of mass
destruction played “only one role” in the vote for
war, while “the 23 writs that authorize force to
remove Saddam” included senators’ own citing of Iraq’s
sanctuary and subsidies for terrorists, among others.
Hanson’s warning: “The next time a Democratic
administration makes a case for using America’s
overwhelming military force to preempt a Milosevic or
a mass murderer in Darfur — and history suggests that
one will — the Democrats’ own present disingenuous
anti-war rhetoric may come back to haunt them.”
Former presidential candidate Patrick J. Buchanan’s
Feb. 20 “Baghdad on the Potomac?” envisioned “war
deaths” to rise in the next 23 months, and said that
opposition to the war, acrimony, bitterness and
recriminations will grow. The “real regime crisis” may
be “right here in River City,” he said. He asked “the
John Edwards Democrats” who apologized for having
voted for war because they did not know then what they
know now: “Why did you get it wrong and vote for
Bush’s war, when Russ Feingold, Ted Kennedy and half
the Democratic Party got it right and voted no?”
The Feb. 17 Washington Post’s editorial, “Not the
‘Real Vote’,” quoted anti-war MoveCongress.org’s
interview with Rep. John Murtha (D-Pa.) that the
House’s resolution disapproving Bush’s troop surge was
not the real vote, which “will come on the legislation
we’re putting together” to “stop the surge” and “force
a redeployment” of American forces from Iraq: “What we
are saying will be very hard to find fault with.”
So Murtha’s aim, the Post said, “is not to improve
readiness (for redeployment) but to ‘stop the surge.’
… So why not straightforwardly strip the money out
of the appropriations bill — an action Congress is
clearly empowered to take — rather than try to
micromanage the Army in a way that may be
unconstitutional?”
The Post warned House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.),
who backed Murtha, of “maneuvering her party in a way
that can only do it harm.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 28, 2007