Read, think, imagine what’s desired. Will it to
happen. Go for it. It’s better to have made efforts
and failed than to have failed and blame karma.
Psychology professor Barbara Held of Bowdoin College
in Maine worries about the “tyranny of the positive
attitude.” She is not against “looking on the bright
side,” but “life is hard for everyone, at least some
of the time.”
Just because one’s “problem” may not be as bad as
another’s, “doesn’t mean (one doesn’t) have the right
to feel bad or experience pain and express that in
appropriate context.” It “can be harmful” to pretend
things are fine when they are not, or one is okay when
one is not; and it “can be helpful … to have a
little more space for people to feel bad.”
Held’s book, “Stop Smiling, Start Kvetching: A 5-Step
Guide to Creative Complaining,” includes a person’s
“inalienable right to kvetch” — Yiddish for complain;
but a “creative kvetcher” doesn’t kvetch to all the
people all the time, and knows when and to whom to
kvetch without driving the listener away.
# Avoid being a kvetcher in denial: “I’m not
complaining, I’m just stating how things are.”
# Avoid being a competitive kvetcher: “You think
you’ve got a problem! Yesterday I ….” Whether one’s
problem is worse than another’s is “irrelevant.”
# Kvetch in moderation to a willing listener;
# Avoid hogging the kvetching; and
# Have respect for the listener.
Kvetching will not make a person healthier physically,
or radically change one’s mental health, but “it may
make you a little less miserable, and given how hard
life is, that’s not bad,” said Held in an interview in
Lisa R. Van Wagner’s “Kvetching for Better Health.”
But senior minister from Christ Church Unity in Kansas
City, Mo., Rev. Will Bowen, author of a 2007 book, “A
Complaint Free World: How to Stop Complaining and
Start Enjoying the Life You Always Wanted,” sees a
direct correlation between the world’s excessive
grumbling and why many people find the world less than
desirable.
On a Sunday in 2006, he suggested to his congregation
of 250 to give up complaining for 21 days (length of
time to break a habit) to start to improve their
lives.
In the Feb. 19 Christian Science Monitor’s “One man’s
crusade to stop the world from complaining,” by David
Conrads, Bowen philosophized, “I strongly believe that
our thoughts create our lives”; “Our words indicate
what we’re thinking.”
Like bad breath
“Complaining is like bad breath,” says Bowen, “You
notice it when it comes out of somebody else’s mouth,
but not when it comes out of your own.” So, if people
stop griping — “gossiping and sarcasm are no-nos,
too” — and start focusing on the way things should
be, the world would be a better place.
The main reason people complain is to “excuse
themselves from taking action … it’s easier (to
complain) than finding a solution.”
Bowen distributed purple silicone bracelets, which he
challenged parishioners to wear on the same wrist for
three straight weeks, but to move from wrist to wrist
when they griped.
What started with 250 people has grown into a
worldwide self-improvement movement, with a slogan —
poet Maya Angelou’s “If you don’t like something,
change it. If you can’t change it, change your
attitude. Don’t complain.”
More than five million bracelets have been sent to
more than 80 countries, with steady requests for about
25,000 bracelets a week.
On Jan. 27, 2007, Los Angeles Times staff writer
Stephanie Simon wrote in “Quit your whining, if you
can,” that her “first attempt at a complaint-free life
lasted 15 minutes,” when she dropped off her kids at
school five days after a blizzard. Unhappy with the
parking lot and the sidewalks, she called to the
principal, “This place is a disaster,” only to
“instantly” regret harping at a man standing in the
cold to make sure students got into school safely.
The Rev. Bowen’s challenge got Simon to resolve “to
quit grumbling.” But Simon “slipped up time and
again,” and confessed to have given “everyone (in the
family) the silent treatment.” She quoted Professor
Held, “Maybe I should start selling ‘It’s OK to
complain’ bracelets.” Simon added, “She’d probably
sell a bundle.”
But Bowen explained: Smashing a finger a week ago, and
say, “Oooh, I hurt my finger! It hurts so bad!” is
complaining, and “99 percent of it is not beneficial”;
saying calmly, “I smashed my finger last week and it
still hurts,” is a statement of fact.
“Everything comes down to the energy you put into it,”
says Bowen. Simon thought maybe she had taken “the
complaint-free life too literally.”
So, “I put aside my purple bracelet” but kept watching
her words, Simon wrote.
After the fourth big storm in a month dumped eight
more inches of snow, Simon tried conversations with
“the beauty of the white-capped Rockies,” until she
had to drive her kids to school again.
“It would be great if the county could send a plow,”
Simon wrote for the Times, and ended her column:
“That’s not a complaint. Just a statement of fact.”
The Christian Science Monitor’s Conrads quoted the
president of the Fuller Theological Seminary in
Pasadena, Calif.: “I say don’t put on rose-colored
glasses and refuse to look at the bad things in life,
but make a special effort to cultivate a more positive
spirit … It’s not healthy to be constantly
complaining, constantly feeling put upon or
mistreated.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 12, 2008