The North Koreans test-fired four short-range missiles July 2 and a series
of seven Scud and Rodong missiles July 4, in defiance of U.N. Security
Council resolutions. The Security Council “condemned and expressed
grave concern” over the launches.
In late June, President Obama declared that the United States “is fully prepared for any contingencies.”
Pyongyang leaders were spared further retribution because their faulty missiles
misfired, although the threat did put South Korea and Japan on edge and
raised regional tensions, as U.S. military facilities on Guam and
Okinawa are not far from North Korea.
The North Korean actions may have overshadowed another event in late June
in China, concerning the South China Sea, when a member of the standing
committee of China’s highest-level advisory body, the Chinese People’s
Political Consultative Conference, Gen. Zhang Li, recommended the
construction of “an airport and seaport on Mischief Reef” in the
Spratly Islands. Li was former deputy chief of the People’s Liberation
Army’s general staff.
The Washington-based Jamestown Foundation, whose proclaimed mission is to
inform and educate policymakers about events and trends in societies
strategically or tactically important to the United States, reported
the event in its China Brief Volume of June 24 — “PLA General Advises
Building Bases in the South China Sea,” by Russell Hsiao.
Hsiao sees Li’s call for a military building in the disputed Spratlys as
“signs of China’s increased willingness to use force in resolving
territorial disputes.”
The Spratly Islands are said to comprise more than 500 islets, of which
Vietnam occupies 29; the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei occupy three
or more islets each. Li asserts that China controls only four.
According to Hsiao, a Chinese media source reported that, under the
direct order of the Central Military Commission under President Hu
Jintao, the Chinese navy has “recently conducted a large-scale naval
exercise” in the South China Sea “to demonstrate Chinese sovereignty
over the islands.”
Hsiao referenced reports in the China Review News and Xinhua News Agency that
China sent eight patrol ships to monitor 128,000 square kilometers of
the region.
Hsiao wrote that Li told the CPPCC standing committee at the June 18 meeting
that the situation in the South China Sea is “very grim,” and
recommended that the Chinese navy add “vessels and boats” with a
displacement of 3,000 tons or higher to operate in the disputed area.
He said, with the construction of the airport and seaport, China can
control the Spratlys, and Chinese naval vessels can bypass the Straits
of Malacca, a strategic choke point for China’s national security.
The South China Sea covers about 3,500,000 square kilometers. The United
Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, or UNCLOS — which came into
force in 1994 and has 170 countries as signatories today — defined
territorial waters as a belt of coastal waters extending, at most, 12
nautical miles from the baseline or low-water mark of a coastal state.
The territorial waters are regarded as the sovereign territory of the
state, although foreign ships are allowed innocent passage through it.
Article 56 of UNCLOS stipulates that the coastal state enjoys sovereign rights
in the Exclusive Economic Zone that extends 200 nautical miles beyond
territorial waters, for purpose of “exploring and exploiting,
conserving and managing the natural resources.” While coastal states
have scrambled to draw their respective EEZ’s, UNCLOS allows nations
only to explore and exploit natural resources, and never to state
ownership. As such, all military and non-military ships may pass
through any nation’s EEZ without having to ask permission.
But in February 1995, China’s Red Flag was flying on the roof of a
Chinese-built structure on stilts on Philippine-claimed Panganiban, or
Mischief Reef, about 135 miles from the Philippine coast of Palawan and
some 800 miles away from China’s southernmost Hainan Island.
In December 1998, a Philippine Air Force C-130 aircraft carrying U.S.
Congressman Dana Rohrabacher of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs
and Chairman Roilo Golez of the Philippine House Committee on Public
Order and Security made six passes flying as low as 300 feet over
Mischief Reef and photographed three landing support vessels with 57mm
guns and a helipad.
Relying on a series of photos taken by Philippine jets in late 1998 and early
1999, Golez accused China of lying about “these huge, concrete,
fortified buildings, … a base for communication, anti-aircraft guns,
radar (and) laser weapons.” In a month, Chinese workers had constructed
these fortified facilities where only stilted structures had once stood.
In January 1999, Philippine Secretary of Defense Orlando Mercado charged
at a press conference that two Chinese Jianghou-type frigates, one
allegedly carrying surface-to-surface missiles, the other with
surface-to-air missiles, were at Mischief, but China denied any
military presence in the area.
Since 2000, Beijing has asserted that its rights over the South China Sea
date back to the Xia Dynasty between the 16th and the 21st centuries.
China has always referred to the South China Sea as a Chinese Lake.
And, thus, the Jamestown report speaks volumes about a perfect storm
that may lie ahead.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where
he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.