Property has been destroyed, national flags have been burned and people killed as emotions run amok, pitting the world of Islam against the West, and all because of 12 cartoons depicting Prophet Muhammad published four months ago in Denmark’s Jyllands-Posten.

Cartoons are satirical drawings that portray serious situations with humor. But there are Muslims who don’t find the Danish caricatures of Muhammad funny; they find them offensive and sacrilegious.

There are Muslims who argue that Islam does not permit imagery of Muhammad. But as protests against the cartoons’ publication has escalated, newspapers in Spain, France, and Germany have republished the cartoons on grounds of defending freedom of speech.

I studied the 12 cartoons. I can see why there are Muslims who are angry: One cartoon shows Muhammad wearing a turban that incorporates an ignited bomb; another shows Muhammad stopping suicide bombers from entering heaven, saying “Stop, stop, we’ve run out of virgins!”  I wonder how many Muslim demonstrators, and how many commentators, have actually seen the drawings?

My mother told me from the time I was a little boy, what neuroscientists have since affirmed: Rational thought shuts down and emotional thought takes over in political argument and reaction. Except my mother said this applies to debate on religion and love, too.

Supporters of Muslims’ “rage” are as virulent in their views as supporters of freedom of speech. Plenty has been written on both sides of this debate in this clash of civilizations.

Danish Premier Anders Fogh Rasmussen referred to protests as “a growing global crisis,” and on Feb. 5 Muslim Turkish Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Christian Spanish Premier Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero declared in the International Herald Tribune in Paris that “it is necessary to make an appeal for respect and calm, and let the voice of reason be heard,” and that unless the situation is “immediately” defused, “We shall all be the losers.”

The Feb. 8 Washington Post’s “The Uses of Cartoons,” editorializes that the “vulgarity and offensiveness” of the cartoons “are beyond question,” and were published as “a calculated insult last September by a right-wing newspaper.” Helena Cobban’s “Respecting both free speech and Muslims’ faith can bring peace” in the Feb. 9 Christian Science Monitor asked, “isn’t this really an issue of ‘freedom of speech’ clashing with the desire to protect the sacred?”

Cobban sees “attacks against certain, very dearly loved symbols of things” as “symbolic violence” that should be avoided. She asked: “Is free speech ‘sacred’ in the same way that a sincere believer’s religion is sacred?” Cobban said she does not think so.

Amir Taheri’s “Bonfire of the Pities, Islam prohibits neither images of Muhammad nor jokes about religion,” in the Feb. 8 Wall Street Journal, and Souheila al-Jadda’s “Understanding the outrage” in the Feb. 8 USA Today, agree that Muhammad’s portraits have and can be done in “honorable ways,” as Persian Muslims have for centuries, and that a statue of Muhammad is currently in the U.S. Supreme Court building.

Egyptian commentator Mona Eltahawy asked in “A Mountain Out Of A Molehill Over Danish Cartoons” on Jan. 28 for Lebanon’s The Daily Star and Egypt’s al-Dostour, “Can we finally admit that Muslims have blown out of all proportion their outage over 12 cartoons depicting the Prophet Muhammad” in a Danish newspaper?

Cal State professor Jamil Momand’s “What would Muhammad do?” in the Feb. 9 Los Angeles Times, asked why Muslims who have “called for the deaths” of cartoonists can’t follow the life and the examples of Muhammad? Spokeswoman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, Rabiah Ahmed, told the Monitor that Muhammad “would turn the other cheek if someone slapped him. He preached love and tolerance.”

In “A Cartoon’s Portrait of America,” Anne Applebaum concluded that the cartoon controversy should end “that naïve, charming and sadly incorrect American theory of international relations that ‘the more we all learn about one another, the less we will fight.'”

In Applebaum’s view, the “Islamic world is learning” gradually that Westerners don’t respect religion in the same way they do, and “we are learning” slowly that they feel differently about printed words and printed pictures.

“And somehow, I’ve got a feeling that this new knowledge will be not the beginning of understanding but the inspiration for more violence.”

 

A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Originally published February 15, 2006