A Sept. 8-11 Washington Post-ABC News poll shows 54
percent of Americans disapprove of President George W.
Bush’s response to Hurricane Katrina; 57 percent blame
state and local officials for the problem; 63 percent
of African-Americans see the delay in mounting relief
efforts as a sign of America’s racial inequality; 77
percent of whites disagree.
Bush’s overall approval rating dropped to 42 percent,
and 57 percent disapprove of the way Bush handles his
job as president.
The Sept. 12 Newsweek report on Katrina asked and
answered: “What went wrong? Just about everything.” It
quoted a National Guardsman, Sgt. Jason Defess, on
duty at the News Orleans Superdome after a 14-month
tour in Iraq: “To tell you the truth, I’d rather be in
Iraq. You got your constant danger, but I had
something to protect myself. Three meals a day.
Communications. A plan. Here, they had no plan.”
On Sept. 13, Bush, known for his aversion to admitting
mistakes and seen by critics as detached and
unconcerned or unaware of what he says or does
(“Oblivious, in denial, dangerous,” said House
Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi), made a first
acknowledgement of personal responsibility for federal
missteps.
“Katrina exposed serious problems in our response
capability at all levels of government. And to the
extent that the federal government didn’t fully do its
job right, I take responsibility,” Bush said.
A Sept. 10 New York Times News Analysis, “Casualty of
Firestorm: Outrage, Bush and FEMA Chief,” speaks about
how Bush realized on Sept. 1 that his administration
was in trouble dealing with the disaster: An aide
showed him a report about the deaths of evacuees at
the convention center, the first time Bush had heard
of it. Reportedly angry, he ordered White House Chief
of Staff Andrew Card to find out what was going on.
Although he was upset with FEMA director Michael D.
Brown, Bush praised him publicly. Then, on Sept. 9,
Brown was removed from management of the disaster, and
three days later tendered his resignation. He was
replaced by R. David Paulison, who has 30 years of
firefighting experience.
In “Living Too Much in the Bubble?” the Sept. 11 Time
magazine speaks of Bush talking to an aide at 5 a.m.
in San Diego about the seriousness of Katrina, and
convening an emergency conference call of his top
staff. Time said Bush decided, “We’re going back” to
Washington and wanted cabinet members recalled from
vacations.
A Sept. 8 USA Today’s News Analysis, “A compassionate
Bush was absent right after Katrina,” said Bush has
shown that he can be “empathic, sensitive and
decisive,” which he was not for days after Katrina.
Bush hurriedly altered his schedule, with priority
given to the Gulf Coast. He toured the coast for the
first time Sept. 2 and “choked back tears.” He visited
again Sept. 5, Sept. 11 and Sept. 15, when he
addressed the nation from New Orleans, vowing to
rebuild the city and the Gulf Coast with “one of the
largest reconstruction efforts the world has ever
known.”
In his speech, Bush admitted that four years after
Sept. 11, “Americans have every right to expect a more
effective response in a time of emergency,” and “I as
president am responsible for the problem, and for the
solution.” He pledged, to “do what it takes … stay
as long as it takes, to help citizens rebuild.”
Some critics say it’s too late for Bush.
Bill Minutaglio, author of a Bush biography, “First
Son,” said, “The right salve for the nation in this
time of great tragedy is missing. People are thirsting
for it. … It can’t be orchestrated, it just has to
happen.” USA Today wrote that an engaged Bush “has the
sort of compassion for which Clinton and Ronald Reagan
were renowned.” “He does have this unique one-on-one
quality to relate to people,” Minutaglio said.
University of Texas communications and government
professor Roderick Hart sees Bush’s initial off-key
reaction to Katrina “an odd case,” noting Bush has “an
ability to reach out to people.”
Washington University political scientist Kathryn Dunn
Tenpas says Bush is now “empathizing and responding in
tangible ways. … He will fare well if he shows that
he is addressing the needs.”
Will Bush survive Katrina?
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published September 21, 2005