In “Now playing in Washington: Gridlock,” the March 27
Christian Science Monitor editorialized that “not long
ago,” Democratic leaders, fresh from their “thumpin'”
of the GOP in the 2006 elections, and President George
- Bush, talked of bipartisan cooperation.
That hopeful moment has evolved into today’s “politics
of war, of congressional oversight and of a premature
presidential campaign (that) will make it very
difficult for this Congress and White House to move
ahead on substantial issues,” like health care,
climate change, entitlement reform, illegal
immigration, that “demand cooperation — today if not
yesterday.”
To move ahead, says the Monitor, Bush “must want to go
out on a note that can be heard above the political
crossfire of the Iraq war” and the Democrats must
desire “to accomplish something beyond their present
focus on oversight.”
“At the moment, that’s hard to imagine,” it says.
The day the House of Representatives voted 218-212 for
a $124 billion Iraq spending bill that orders United
States combat troops to leave Iraq by Aug. 31, 2008,
saw an editorial, “Retreat and Butter,” in the
Washington Post, the nation’s capital’s newspaper, a
critic of Bush’s handling of the Iraq War.
“Democrats who want to force a withdrawal should vote
against war appropriations,” says the Post, and “not
seek to use pork to buy a majority for an
unconditional retreat that the majority does not
support.”
The Post asks, “Are Democrats in the House voting for
farm subsidies or withdrawal from Iraq?”
It sees lawmakers who voted for the bill that imposes
a fixed U.S. withdrawal date “regardless of what
happens during the next 17 months or whether U.S.
commanders believe a pullout at that moment protects
or endangers U.S. national security” and careless of
what will happen to U.S. trainers and troops who will
“remain behind” as paying “more heed to a handful of
peanut farmers than to the 24 million Iraqis who are
living through a maelstrom initiated by the United
States, the outcome of which could shape the future of
the Middle East for decades.”
The bill “would heap money on unnecessary dairy
farmers while provoking a constitutional fight with
the White House that could block the funding to equip
troops in the field,” warns the Post.
On March 29, in a 51-47 vote, the Senate passed the
$122 billion legislation that orders Bush to start
bringing troops home within 120 days and presents a
nonbinding goal of ending combat operations by March
31, 2008.
The Los Angeles Times says the withdrawal language “is
wrongheaded” and that “it is bad precedent and bad
public policy for Congress to attempt to micromanage
military operations in Iraq.”
The Times added, “If a majority of the people’s
representatives conclude that the effort to stabilize
Iraq has failed, then Congress should vote to cut off
funding.” Bush, who claims funds for the war are
needed by mid-April, summoned House Republicans to
prepare for a veto fight with Democrats.
The Monitor says Congress and the White House have a
choice: either make this “a productive legislative
period” like at the end of Reagan’s second term, or
one “far less so,” like at the end of the Clinton era.
In the March 28 Los Angeles Times, Ronald Brownstein
writes in “Bush and Democrats: Enemies who need each
other” that, “The tragedy in the escalating
confrontation between President Bush and the
Democratic Congress over Iraq is that each has
something the other needs.”
“Because neither” Bush nor congressional Democrats can
“set a sustainable course” alone, their choice is:
“either to continue colliding in polarized
confrontation … or seek agreement on a strategy for
Iraq that a broader coalition in Congress and the
country might support,” argues Brownstein.
The March 21 New York Times’ “The Troika and the
Surge,” by Thomas Friedman, asserts that Bush’s surge
is going ahead, because he has the “authority to do it
and the veto power to prevent anyone from stopping
him.” What’s left is to “hope that it works.”
Retired U.S. Army Gen. Barry R. McCaffrey, professor
of international studies at West Point, writes in his
“After Action Report” that “The consequence of failure
will be severe.”
Had Republican lawmakers not “sat in mute silence the
last four years,” but questioned “Don Rumsfeld’s
ignorant bromides” and demanded the White House to
“account for failure in Iraq, we might have had the
surge in 2003 … rather than in 2007, when the
chances of success are much diminished,” argues
Friedman.
He posits that House Speaker Pelosi’s demand for a
withdrawal deadline actually helps Gen. David
Petraeus, who can tell Iraqi politicians: “Look guys,
Pelosi’s mad as hell — and she has a big following! I
don’t want to quit, but Americans won’t stick with
this forever. I only have a few months.”
Petraeus says we should know if the surge is working
by “late summer.” “We need to root for Gen. Petraeus
to succeed,” says Friedman, a critic of Bush. “Since
Bush is going to be Bush, let Pelosi be Pelosi and
Petraeus be Petraeus … we don’t have much choice.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published April 4, 2007