Tolerance for one another’s cultural, religious and
political views in today’s American society seems to
be at a low ebb. Not only are Americans deeply divided
on immigration reform, an unhealthy American-immigrant
relationship has negative consequences for the nation.
About 12 million illegal immigrants are on U.S. soil.
The House of Representatives wants to criminalize and
deport illegal immigrants, build a fence to prevent
their entry to the United States and penalize
employers for hiring them.
The Senate wants a more comprehensive solution, to
include a “guest worker” program and conditions
allowing a majority of illegals to eventually become
legal permanent residents and citizens.
The differences between the two pieces of legislation,
which must be reconciled for a bill to become law,
have led some 30 states to adopt bills and pass laws
to penalize employers and deny illegals public
services and state benefits. Nov. 7 elections are
likely to prevent action on immigration reform before
then.
“Hoy marchamos, mañana votamos,” or “Today we march,
tomorrow we vote,” was the chant of legal and illegal
immigrants and Americans in the nationwide May 1
boycott that called for “no work, no school, no
shopping, no commerce” and demanded “full rights” for
illegal immigrants.
“La ley es la ley,” the law is the law. Legalizing the
illegals?
“Mañana” comes Nov. 7. Immigrant rights activists have
vowed to mobilize “new voters,” mostly Hispanics, to
vote. The July 12 USA Today’s “Immigrant groups’ aim:
Turn marchers to voters,” quoted Center for Community
Change executive director Cristina Lopez: “Our
community will turn out when they are angry. And our
community is very angry.”
Anti-illegal-immigration Colorado Republican
congressman Tom Tancredo warned this could backfire:
“It could be a rallying cry used by people on our
side, … to look at what the other side is doing, and
get out and vote.”
Widely reported by the media on July 10 was Marine
Gen. Peter Pace, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of
Staff, who emotionally described to a Senate hearing
on immigration his Italian immigrant father’s struggle
in New York City, working three jobs and raising four
children, “but the jobs were there for him, and the
opportunities were there for him,” he said.
“There is no other country on the planet that affords
that kind of opportunity to those who come here,” Pace
told the committee.
He said he is “still on active duty today for one
primary reason, and that is I still owe those
(immigrant soldiers) who served with me in Vietnam.”
He said non-U.S. citizen soldiers in Afghanistan and
Iraq have been given 200 awards and medals, and 101
non-U.S. citizen soldiers have died in military action
since Sept. 11, 2001.
Paul Greenberg’s “Conscience of a conservative” in the
July 12 townhall.com wrote bitterly about demands that
“all illegal immigrants be deported, even if that
means breaking up families, disrupting the economy and
denying immigrant mothers medical care and their
children an equal right to a college education.”
The children will not “forget how their families,
their mothers and fathers, were treated once they grow
up to become voters, as they surely will,” Greenberg
wrote, and “Cracking down on these newcomers and their
children may be a good way to win the next election —
and lose the next generation.”
The July 10 Wall Street Journal’s “Enforcement Isn’t
Enough” recalled John Adams’ “Facts are stubborn
things,” and argued it “is a fact of life in the U.S.
today” that a “robust annual flow” of immigration is
“required to keep our economy growing” and that there
are about 12 million illegals “already in the
country.” It sees “the only practical way to deal with
these stubborn realities” is a comprehensive solution
that includes border security, enforcing the law in
the workplace, creating legal channels for workers to
enter the United States through a guest worker
program, and regularizing the status of illegals
already here.
In “Conservatives and Immigration,” the Journal, which
editorialized about “free markets and free people,”
“freedom and human dignity,” and how “immigrants
contribute far more to our economy than they extract
in public benefits,” slammed groups on the left, La
Raza and the Mexican American Legal Defense and
Education Fund, as doing “the cause of immigration no
good” by pushing for “multiculturalism, bilingual
education, foreign language ballots, racial quotas and
the like.”
They “undermine support for immigration” from “even
the most open-minded Americans.”
Cool heads among Americans and immigrants can bring
people together.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published July 19, 2006