Comparative analysis, my field of specialization in graduate school and in life experiences, is a study of the lifeways of other peoples around the globe. Learning about others’ ways of thinking and doing things help us to understand those beyond our borders. The comparisons lead to greater self-awareness and to an appreciation of unfamiliar methods and processes.
Whether the world is getting smaller as the technology revolution and transportation improvements bring peoples closer to one another, or the distances between us are increasing as interaction and familiarity cause some to hold tight to their ways and keep others’ different ways at an arm’s length, we cannot reject the truth that, in our globalized world, there exists an interconnectedness between and among peoples, cultures, societies and economies. This interdependence means that what happens somewhere, near or far, will — sooner or later, directly or indirectly — reach our doorstep.
Knowledge and understanding of what occurs elsewhere and how others think, behave and act prepare us for the effects of change and for change itself. Gaining this knowledge and understanding is part of being a responsible world citizen.
An interesting fact has no value, in and of itself, but the act of relating or comparing this knowledge with other information allows us to evaluate similarities and differences, analyze them, and look for causes and effects.
In comparative analysis and in world politics, the interest is in discerning patterns of behavior and action. Patterns allow for generalizations, which in turn allow us to develop theories to predict what lies ahead. From these theories, solutions can be devised to meet challenges and avoid conflict and chaos.
In 2003, the Pacific Daily News published my column in this space, “African author’s lessons hold true for plight of education on Guam,” a column that remains valid today. In it, I dealt with “Does Africa Need a Cultural Adjustment Program?” by Cameroonian Daniel Etounga-Manguelle, founder of an African study society that was involved in more than 50 development projects in west, central and southern Africa, and a former member of the World Bank’s Council of African Advisors. He sees African diversity as a vast number of subcultures” (Arabophone, Anglophone, Francophone, Lusophone, Hispanophone, and cores of languages in “Fifty Africa, a Single Culture?”) and asks, “Does generalizing about African culture as a whole make any sense at all?”
“I believe that it does,” says Etounga-Manguelle, who sees underneath African diversity, “shared values, attitudes, and institutions that binds together” the nations of Africa. He provides a “typology” of “African cultural reality”:
Africans’ “vertical societies” see members subordinate themselves to the superiors whose “strength prevails above law”; Africans who subordinate the individual to the community have no concept of African individual responsibility; Africans who see time and space as a single entity are immersed in the present with little concern about the future. Africans work to live and do not live to work, Etounga-Manguelle contends, “Everything is a pretext for celebration” — lots of food with maximum guests — and “friendship comes before business.” He explained Africans’ social peace in terms of avoiding conflict.
Comparing African societies to a football team that lacks team spirit and whose members are rivals, he cites an African proverb, “He who looks from the bottom of a well sees only a portion of the sky,” reminds Africans they “can no longer reasonably blame the colonial powers for our condition” since Africans have become independent for decades, and asks his fellow Africans to look in the mirror and look themselves in the face.
Etounga-Manguelle calls for modifications to certain aspects of the “powerful, immovable culture” because “we are condemned either to change or to perish.”
He proposes peaceful cultural revolution in education, politics, economic and social life, and calls for critical thinking and qualities that engender progress that include imagination, dissent, creativity, professionalism, competence, a sense of responsibility and duty, as well as love for a job well done.
“Once education has been reformed, African political systems will change virtually by themselves,” writes the Cameroonian. Reminding that “culture is the mother and that institutions are the children,” he appeals, “We must go to the heart of our morals and customs in order to eradicate the layer of mud that prevents our societies from moving into modernization.”
“More efficient and just African institutions dependon modifications to our culture,” Etounga-Manguelle concludes his article in “Culture Matters: How Values Shape Human Progress,” edited by Lawrence E. Harrison and Samuel P. Huntington of Harvard University.
Learning about others’ lifeways help us learn about and understand ourselves. Development and progress demand that we do so.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 8, 2007