More than one election observer has warned, as has
William Schneider in the Oct. 24 Atlantic Online, that
the midterm elections may turn out to be “another
endless election” with slow balloting results because
of close races, the prevalence of eager lawyers in
both camps, and — perhaps most of all —
“touch-screen machines that produce no paper trail.”
Having seen some revolting political campaign ads, I
wonder if political disagreement has not already
polarized some family members, friends and co-workers,
leaving permanent scars. America’s national interests
require both parties to work together on major issues.
The nation should come first.
Last month’s Newsweek poll says Republican ads have
turned off more voters than Democratic ads did, but
Democratic ads have attracted and turned off roughly
equal numbers of voters. Many voters are fed up with
negativity.
The “cut-and-run” rhetoric has inflamed and polarized.
“He Lies, People Die” is a slogan with the same
effect. Bashing one another and being angry over where
we are today doesn’t change where we are. Pick up the
pieces, learn our lessons and move on; we’ll be in a
different place.
An example of the impact of a consensus view can be
found in the recently declassified “Key Judgments” of
the April 2006 National Intelligence Estimate’s
“Trends in Global Terrorism: Implications for the
United States,” which reported the common findings of
all of the United States’ 16 intelligence agencies.
The report said the Iraq war draws Islamic “jihadists”
to fight, and their “increasing attacks worldwide” are
expected; jihadists’ “perceived” success would
“inspire more fighters” to “struggle elsewhere,” but
if jihadists “perceive themselves, and be perceived,
to have failed,” then “fewer fighters will be inspired
to carry on the fight.”
The choices are not good. In the midst of the ugly
sectarian violence, it’s U.S. troops who separate the
fighters, for now, while they wait for America to
leave so they can try to grab power.
Richard Holbrooke, former ambassador to the United
Nations, rejected a “fixed timetable for withdrawal”
from Iraq, suggesting “the least bad option” for
President Bush, in a recent column in the Washington
Post, is to “disengage from the civil war already
underway, focus maximum effort on seeking a political
power-sharing agreement, and try to limit further
damage in the region and the world.”
In the Nov. 6 Newsweek, “We’re losing, but all isn’t
lost. The Road Out of Iraq,” international editor
Fareed Zakaria despairs over how Shiites are “dead
set” against sharing power with Sunnis and Sunnis are
so consumed by “anger, radicalism and feuds” that they
become “blind to the reality that if not for U.S.
forces, they would be massacred.”
More troops, more money and more time would not make
much difference in Iraq, he says, and except for the
Kurds, many Iraqi leaders “play a nasty game,”
publicly condemning the U.S. presence while they,
“more quietly, assent to America’s continued
involvement.” Among other things, he suggests Iraq’s
Parliament “publicly ask American troops to stay” or
the U.S. presence would be “politically untenable” in
both Iraq and America; and that Americans “talk to
Iraq’s neighbors” about their common interest in
Iraq’s security and stability.
Zakaria warned if U.S. troops “pack up and go home …
the bloodletting would spread like a virus.”
In the Oct. 31 Wall Street Journal Online’s “Losing Is
Not an Option,” Omar Fadhil, an Iraqi who runs “Iraq
the Model,” a blog based in Baghdad, says the
situation in Iraq is “bad for Iraqis and Americans
alike,” but “losing” in Iraq will bring “great
subsequent losses” to Iraq and the world by creating a
“gigantic octopus of terrorists and terror-supporting
regimes” extending from Afghanistan to Libya, and from
Iraq to Sudan and Somalia.
The Oct. 28-Nov. 3 London Economist editorializes in
“Cut and run?” that America’s voters “are entitled to
punish George Bush” but that “Americans would be wrong
to extend this punishment to the people of Iraq.”
“Even if it was a mistake to blunder into Iraq,” it
said, “it would be a bigger mistake, bordering on a
crime, for a nation that aspires to greatness to
blunder out now, without first having exhausted every
possible effort to put Iraq back together and avert a
wider war.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published November 8, 2006