Throughout human history, people have migrated for one reason or another. This has become particularly true in this age of globalization.
Immigration rights organizers planned to hold a nationwide boycott of work, school and shopping on Monday in an effort to persuade Congress to pass immigration reform legislation that would grant full legalization of illegal immigrants, or “undocumented workers,” on U.S. soil.
A research organization in Washington, the Pew Hispanic Center, estimates there are between 11 million and 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States, of whom 6.2 million, or 56 percent, are from Mexico, with about 850,000 having arrived annually since 2000.
About 2.5 million illegal immigrants are from Central and Latin America; 1.5 million from Asia; some 600,000 are from Europe and Canada; and about 400,000 are from Africa and other countries.
The United States has about 13.1 legal immigrants, excluding naturalized citizens.
The March 29 New York Times reported that while the United States has always been a nation of immigrants, the country has more than 33 million foreign-born residents today, the largest number since 1850, when such statistics began being recorded.
The question is what to do with the 11 million to 12 million illegal immigrants already on U.S. soil?
The Act Now to Stop War & End Racism (ANSWER) coalition — which includes the Free Palestine Alliance, the Korea Truth Commission, the Party for Socialism and Liberation, to name a few – organized the massive March 25 Los Angeles rally. It called for “full rights for undocumented workers” and condemned as “racism” congressional efforts to criminalize illegal immigrants.
With a vote of 239-182, the House of Representatives has passed a bill which, among other things, would make illegal immigrants felons and helping them to enter U.S. soil a federal crime. The Senate, which favored allowing illegal immigrants to stay in the country under specified conditions, failed to reach an agreement before Congress recessed.
In “Public divided over how to treat illegals,” the April 10 USA Today reported on a USA Today/Gallup Poll survey from April 14-16, which found the American public holding the “same almost-contradictory attitudes about immigration” as the U.S. Congress does.
While a majority of Americans surveyed want to make illegal immigration a crime for immigrants and those who help them, almost two-thirds say illegal immigrants should be able to stay and become U.S. citizens if they meet certain requirements over time.
USA Today reported that fewer than one in five Americans think that all illegal immigrants should be deported; and a similar number say they should be allowed to stay and work for a limited time.
Sixty-three percent say there should be a way for illegal immigrants to stay and work in the United States and become citizens if they meet certain requirements.
According to the survey, eight in 10 Americans list those requirements as: having a job, learning to speak English, passing a health screening and paying federal taxes due on past income. Two-thirds of those surveyed say illegal immigrants should be required to have lived in the United States for at least five years and pay a fine for entering U.S. soil illegally.
USA Today revealed its own poll, showing only 29 percent of Americans say they approve of President Bush’s handling of immigrants, while 62 percent disapprove.
The USA Today/Gallup Poll survey shows eight in 10 Americans say illegal immigration in the United States is “out of control,” and nine in 10 say the U.S. government must take measures this year to control the borders and deal with illegal immigrants who already are on U.S. soil.
Whereas Americans are split, 48 percent to 49 percent, over the effectiveness of building a wall along the 700-mile U.S.-Mexican border, 84 percent say tough penalties for businesses that employ illegal immigrants would be an effective measure.
In the April 20 Washington Post’s “Conspiracy Against Assimilation,” Robert J. Samuelson wrote about America’s glory in having assimilated waves of immigrants — Germans, Irish, Jews, Italians – who had encountered economic hardship, prejudice and discrimination, until “outsiders have become insiders.”
“It’s all about assimilation — or it should be,” says Samuelson, who argued that both sides in America’s bitter debate on immigration “are leading us astray.”
Their proposals, “if adopted, would frustrate assimilation,” he says, and “if today’s wave of immigration does not end in assimilation, it will be a failure.”
Samuelson advises us to “heed history’s lessons” and allow “outsiders” and “insiders” time to adapt to each other.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published April 26, 2006