Problems with the Dubai Ports World deal — which
would give management rights over certain American
seaports to an Arab company owned and directly
controlled by the Dubai royal family of the United
Arab Emirates — are unlikely to go away despite the
45-day national security investigation.
Post-Sept. 11 America is not what the country once
was, and post-Sept. 11 Americans who saw the Twin
Towers brought down by terrorists are anxious,
especially since two of the hijackers were from the
United Arab Emirates, where terror planning and
financial transactions occurred and where, recently,
Pakistani scientist A.Q. Khan used the country as a
shipping route for his nuclear network.
Since Sept. 11, 2001, President George W. Bush has
staked his political fortunes on appearing to be tough
on national security issues. But even before the
security investigation has started, Bush, who admitted
he did not know about the Jan. 17 approved deal,
threatened on Feb. 22 to veto legislation opposing the
deal and declared in March he will stand by the ports
deal unless there is a “true security threat” to the
country.
“What kind of signal does it send throughout the world
if it’s OK for a British company to manage the ports
but not a company that has been secured — that has
been cleared for security purposes — from the Arab
world?” Bush asked. He reaffirmed: “My position hasn’t
changed.”
A CBS News poll released on Feb. 27 shows 70 percent
of Americans are opposed to the deal, and only 21
percent support it — a Rasmussen survey shows only 17
percent of Americans support it.
The CBS poll also shows that Bush’s job rating has
fallen eight points, from 42 percent in January to an
all-time low of 34 percent in late February.
Wikipedia.org says the Dubai Ports World deal involved
not just six American seaports, but 22 ports in all.
In addition to the operations rights at up to 30
percent of the terminals at each of the six ports,
Wikipedia says Dubai Ports World would take over
stevedore services at 12 East Coast ports that include
Portland, Maine; Boston; Davisville, R.I.; Camden,
N.J.; Wilmington, Del.; and Newport News, Norfolk, and
Portsmouth in Virginia; and at nine ports along the
Gulf of Mexico, including Beaumont, Port Arthur,
Galveston, Houston, Freeport and Corpus Christi in
Texas, and the Louisiana port of Lake Charles.
The front page of the March 2 Washington Post reported
that a national investigation is also needed for a
second Dubai firm, Dubai International Capital, which
has acquired from the London-based Doncasters Group
Ltd. “plants in Georgia and Connecticut that make
precision components” for military aircraft and tanks.
An Israeli firm that plans to buy the Maryland
software security firm Sourcefire that does business
with Defense Department agencies, also is being
investigated.
Supporters and opponents of the ports deal are not the
usual liberal-conservative dichotomy. The Wall Street
Journal, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times,
former presidents Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter, Rush
Limbaugh and Bill O’Reilly are among supporters of the
deal; The New York Times, The New Republic, the
Washington Times, the Heritage Foundation, Laura
Ingraham and Hillary Clinton, among others, are
opposed.
Weakest links
Grandstanding and politics aside, all agree that
America’s ports represent the most vulnerable aspect
and weakest links of America’s homeland security.
Bridging the gaps in security is where all efforts
should be concentrated.
The Feb. 26 Sunday New York Times’ “Gaps in Security
Stretch All Along the Way From Model Port in Dubai to
U.S.” is a must-read. True, the U.S. Coast Guard and
the U.S. Customs enforce security at the ports, but
about 25,000 shipping containers, each the size of a
small home, enter America’s 361 ports daily, and U.S.
officials conduct gamma screening or manual inspection
of only 5.6 percent of all imported containers, says
the Times. U.S. officials are placed at 42 foreign
ports to monitor screening of high-risk containers,
but some containers are loaded onto the ship before
inspection, and there have been inspection requests
refused by “native port officials.”
While a container from a warehouse overseas to one on
U.S. soil “changes hands multiple times,” the Times
says, “About 37 percent of trucks or rail cars leaving
U.S. ports drive through radiation portals to check
for nuclear material.”
Clearly, America’s vulnerabilities extend from all
foreign ports to U.S. ports, and to U.S. homes.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published March 8, 2006