Valuable comments from readers, on and off island, to
my column, “America, watch out, as nations run past us
in global economy,” in the Oct. 5, 2005, Pacific Daily
News, led me to read with greater interest “How Long
Will America Lead The World?” by Newsweek
International Editor Fareed Zakaria in the magazine’s
June 12 issue, and the June 12 PDN’s “Our country is
being led astray, away from its virtues and
principles.”
I tried to sort out for myself an understanding of
whether “we, the people” are innocents, or if
political leaders are guiding us into an unacceptable
state of affairs.
ADVERTISEMENT
My former students may remember the “lesson of the
index finger” — point it at someone and three fingers
will point back to you while your thumb points to
heaven. There is always plenty of blame to be
apportioned. If we are, indeed, misguided, we, the
people, need to organize and change our leaders.
A year ago, my PDN column referenced Matt Miller’s “Is
Persuasion Dead?” from Fortune magazine. Miller asked
if it’s possible in America today to “convince anyone
of anything he doesn’t already believe.” He said, “the
signs are not good,” since “90 percent” of political
conversation rests on dueling talking points, folks
buy books to reinforce their own opinions, and radio
and opinion journals preach to the converted.
I noted in my 2005 column how Pulitzer Prize-winner
Thomas L. Friedman called on parents to “throw away
the GameBoy, turn off the television and get your kids
to work” because “three billion” non-Western and
non-white people are leveling the playing field to
compete with America, and there is “no guarantee” that
Americans and Western Europeans will continue to lead
the world. Friedman is worried about America’s future.
Zakaria, too, worries about America’s future, though
America remains a world leader: The United States
makes up 29 percent of the world’s output, is the
second-most competitive economy in the world
(according to the World Economic Forum), and is the
first in technology and innovation, technological
readiness, company spending for research and
technology and the quality of research institutions.
“In virtually every sector that advanced industrial
countries participate in, U.S. firms lead the world in
productivity and profits,” he wrote. And in the
London-based Center for European Reform’s recent
report: of the world’s 20 top universities, 18 are
American; the world’s 1,000 best computer scientists
were trained in the top 10 schools, which were
American; and the United States “remains by far the
most attractive destination for students,” taking in
30 percent of all foreign students.
‘Consumption and leisure’
But Zakaria warned that the United States is “becoming
a post-industrial society that specializes in
consumption and leisure.” He quoted the CEO of General
Electric, Jeffrey Immelt, who asserted, “More people
will graduate in the United States in 2006 with
sports-exercise degrees than electrical-engineering
degrees,” and “if we want to be the massage capital of
the world, we’re well on our way.”
Zakaria worries that “mainstream America” is not yet
conscious of how quickly the people of China and India
are catching up, with “an almost limitless supply of
low-skilled labor” and “a fairly large group of highly
skilled workers.”
Yes, I read the May 19 Chronicle of Higher Learning’s
articles about problems of education in Chinese
schools, and I also read the June 8 Asia Society’s
report on the topic.
And I also read what Harry Lewis, a 32-year veteran
faculty at Harvard, and a former Harvard dean, said in
his provocative book, “Excellence Without a Soul” —
American universities have failed in the fundamental
goal of undergraduate education, to make young people
into adults with responsibility for society. Students
are less challenged to grow in wisdom and become
responsible leaders for America’s future.
America’s future? In the June 7 New York Times’ “A
Well of Smiths and Xias,” Friedman listed major
worries in America today, but “there is one reason to
still be optimistic.” He wrote about “the stunning
diversity — race, religion, ethnicity” of the June 5
Montgomery Blair high school graduation. He remembers
his high school graduation in Minnesota, when there
were “five” students “not named Smith” while there
were among the 800 or so seniors at Blair and “exactly
five” graduates” were named Smith.” The rest?
They are Muhammad Waqar, Avi Wolfman-Arent, Yiran Xia,
Nardos Teklebrahan, Matiwos Wonsen … Yueyang Li,
Yoel Castillio-Ortiz, Elijah Zuares …
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 21, 2006