Policies, politics and ideological beliefs polarize Americans today. Abroad, America’s name has lost some luster in the eyes of many nations.
Americans, who were divided into so-called red-staters and blue-staters during the presidential campaign, have continued to be divided since the Nov. 2 election that gave the presidency to George W. Bush, both in popular votes and electoral votes. A political cartoon depicted the “United States of Canada” next to “Jesusland.” Was that funny or sad?
“Politics has become all too personal,” wrote the Christian Science Monitor in October. “The red-blue split among Americans reaches into homes, offices and social circles.”
A CBS/New York Times poll showed, one day before Bush was inaugurated, that 58 percent of Americans are generally optimistic, but that only 39 percent say the country is on the right track, while 56 percent say it is not. Bush’s approval rating of 49 percent trails every re-elected U.S. president in the last half-century.
Abroad, a BBC World Service Poll of 22,000 people in Africa, Latin America, North America, Asia and Europe revealed on Jan. 20 that 58 percent of those surveyed in 16 of 21 nations believe that, in his second term, Bush will affect world peace and security negatively.
I was interested in the Jan. 20 New York Times Op-Ed column, “Four More Years of Happiness,” by Harvard psychologist Daniel Gilbert.
“By now, most of the people I know should be Canadians,” Gilbert wrote, “At least that’s what they said they’d be if President Bush won re-election. And yet, my unofficial tally suggests that the number of disgruntled Democrats who actually emigrated northward is roughly zero, plus or minus none.”
At the inauguration, enthused supporters of Bush and vocal protesters against Bush were noisy. On the ceremony platform, Democrats and Republicans were polite; John Kerry even smiled and applauded occasionally.
Bush’s “freedom” address, very Wilsonian, proclaimed as “the policy of the United States to seek and support the growth of democratic movements and institutions in every nation and culture, with the ultimate goal of ending tyranny in our world.” The speech has been the source of controversy and debate.
Critics attack and ridicule the gap between ideals and realities, and ask how Bush is going to attain his goal. Backers cheer the idealism that sets goals that will require generations, not just four years, to achieve.
Psychologist Gilbert, who contended that people typically overestimate the intensity and duration of their emotional reactions to adversity, said research suggests people have a remarkable ability to manufacture happiness. After “cursing, wailing and gnashing of teeth” in some quarters in November, Gilbert wrote, the weeping subsided in December. He said not to worry: Democrats and Republicans would find satisfaction in themselves in the America after Jan. 20 that would no longer be a political party but an American nation.
Candy Schulman of New York remarked in the Times that perhaps there are a lot of happy Democrats where Gilbert lives, but “the Democrats I know remain truly, deeply disturbed” about the election, and “Oh yes, I have one friend who seems genuinely happy — but he voted for President Bush.”
The Jan. 21 New York Times editorialized that Inauguration Day is about the presidency, not the president. Hence, the inauguration worked as it should, and those who did not vote for Bush did participate and acknowledge the chief executive and come to terms with the process that got him there. The Washington Post’s editorial agrees with Bush’s policy, “which, until now, Mr. Bush has not pursued,” to refuse to ignore or excuse oppression.
The Post warned that U.S. policy toward some countries “is on the verge of a historic change.” The Los Angeles Times editorial said “President Bush’s speech was impressive, and also frightening to those who suspect that he really meant it.”
While the polarization of Americans continues, a series in the Christian Science Monitor, “Talking with the Enemy,” which began in October, “to help Americans bridge the bitter red-blue divide,” is a must read.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., retired from the University of Guam where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published February 2, 2005