American philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson says, “Our
best thoughts come from others.”
The problem is, for different reasons many people
derail learning by drawing their conclusions too soon,
based on incomplete information. They inadvertently
close themselves off from an array of enriching
resources.
Last year, in the Washington Post’s “How to Keep
America Competitive” (Feb. 25), Bill Gates, chairman
of Microsoft Corporation, wrote, “Innovation is the
source of U.S. economic leadership and the foundation
for competitiveness in the global economy,” with its
workforce as “the most important factor.”
He argued, “if we are to remain competitive, we need a
workforce that consists of the world’s brightest
minds.” There’s nothing to disagree with here.
Fareed Zakaria of Newsweek affirmed, the U.S. system
“is very good at developing the critical faculties of
the mind,” and reminds us that foreign governments
send observers to U.S. schools “to learn how to create
a system that nurtures and rewards ingenuity, quick
thinking, and problem-solving.”
Gates has called for “strong schools” for “young
Americans (to) enter the workforce with the math,
science and problem-solving skills they need to
succeed in the knowledge economy.” He laments, out of
29 industrialized nations surveyed, U.S. high school
students ranked 24th on an international math test in
2003.
In 2007, he wrote about America’s “crisis point”:
computer science employment is “growing by nearly
100,000 jobs annually,” but there’s a “dramatic
decline in the number of students graduating with
computer science degrees.”
Yet, 25 years ago America’s National Commission on
Excellence in Education reported in “A Nation At Risk”
that “Our Nation is at risk … the educational
foundations of our society are presently being eroded
by a rising tide of mediocrity that threatens our very
future as a Nation and a people.”
“What was unimaginable a generation ago,” the April
1983 report says, “has begun to occur – others are
matching and surpassing our educational attainments.”
The report recommended, among other things, “far more
homework”; the teaching of English, mathematics,
science, social studies, computer science, each area
with specific purposes; as well as the learning of a
foreign language in elementary grades.
In April 2008, “A Stagnant Nation: Why American
Students Are Still at Risk,” charges that “stunningly
few of the Commission’s recommendations actually have
been enacted” because of politics; the U.S. once
ranked first in graduation rates, “has now fallen to
21st among industrialized nations.” It asserts, “We
cannot afford to graduate millions of high school
seniors who lack skills in reading and math that they
should have learned in middle school.”
Falling behind
“Wake up. We are falling behind daily,” the April 30
USA Today’s Greg Toppo quoted Bob Compton of Harvard
Business School, an entrepreneur, angel investor, and
professional venture capitalist, who has been active
in over 30 businesses.
Erik Hromadka’s “2 Million Minutes, How high school
students in China, India and Indiana are spending
their time,” in the February Indiana Business cover
story, “Is Time Running Out?” is a must read.
In 2005, Compton traveled on business across India, to
which a growing number of U.S. technology jobs are
“being outsourced” — an “economic tectonic shift”
taking place in the world. He said he found his
“seminal moment” when he asked 5- and 6-year-old first
graders in a Bangalore classroom what they want to be
when they grow up. “Most of them said engineers or
scientists,” compared to American children who
“aspired to be rock stars and professional athletes .
The one word that was never mentioned (by American
children) was ‘engineer’ and that just shook me to the
core.”
Compton sees “strong math and science skills … will
allow people in the 21st century to earn high wages,”
and that “capital and opportunity are going to flow to
where the brains are.”
Compton set out to spend 20 months to make the
documentary film “Two Million Minutes”
(www.2Mminutes.com) about how high school students in
Bangalore, students in Shanghai, and at Indiana’s
Carmel High School, among the top five percent of high
schools in the U.S., compare and contrast; how they
allocate their time in class and at home studying,
playing sports, working, sleeping, goofing off,
“affecting their economic prospects for the rest of
their lives.”
Of the 2 million minutes, the Chinese spend 583,200
minutes on school work, the Indians, 422,400 minutes,
and the Americans, 302,400 minutes, Indiana Business
reported.
In the June 2004 New York Times’s “Doing Our
Homework,” Thomas Friedman wrote he now tells his
daughters, “Finish your homework — people in China
and India are starving for your job.” The USA Today
reminds there are 1.1 billion people in India and 1.3
billion in China who want American children’s
“education, prosperity and, someday, their jobs.”
In Hromadka’s words, the film shows Indian and Chinese
students “work in schools with far fewer resources,
live with a much lower standard of living and put much
more effort on academics.”
As Toppo reported, the film “finds plenty (for
Americans) to be worried about: not enough study or
homework time, not enough parental pressure, not
enough focus on math or engineering. American teens
… are preoccupied with sports, after-school jobs and
leisure.”
Americans need to be concerned about their ability to
remain globally competitive.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political
sciencefor 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com