A columnist for Fortune, Matt Miller, whose “Is
Persuasion Dead?” in the June 4 New York Times asked
if it is possible in America today to “convince anyone
of anything he doesn’t already believe,” asserted that
“the signs are not good.” He observed that 90 percent
of political conversation rests on dueling talking
points. Best-selling books are bought by folks to
reinforce their own opinions. Radio and opinion
journals preach to the converted.
Let’s face it, says Miller, the purpose of most
political speeches is “not to persuade but to win, be
it power, ratings, celebrity or even cash.”
Miller says he had not thought much about Iraq until
he read Ken Pollack’s, “The Threatening Storm: The
Case for Invading Iraq,” which Miller saw as “a
platonic ideal of careful analysis meant to persuade.”
Miller confessed, “I was persuaded!” and asked, “So
what should we conclude when a talent like Pollack can
convince us — and then the whole thing turns out to
be based on a premise (weapons of mass destruction)
that is false? … If serious efforts to get it right
can lead to tragic errors, why care about a culture of
persuasion?”
Many articles and books have been and will be written
about Iraq. We, myself included, have quoted somebody
or something to support our thinking. Miller, who
argued that on one level that everyone needs a good
rationalization at the core of his professional life,
says his “holds that the struggle to think things
through, even when we fail, is redeeming.”
In that vein, I find myself sympathetic with the views
expressed by several others recently.
On June 16 a bipartisan group of lawmakers introduced
a resolution demanding President Bush submit a plan by
the end of the year and begin withdrawing U.S. troops
by October 2006.
The June 17 Los Angeles Times quoted a Gallup poll’s
finding that six in 10 Americans believe in partial or
full withdrawal, and an Associated Press-Ipsos poll
found that 41 percent of Americans approve of Bush’s
handling of Iraq, “the worst grade to date.”
David Ignatius’s “Saving Project Iraq” in the June 17
Washington Post argued that “as bad as things are” in
Iraq, the situation does not present “a rationale for
pulling U.S. troops out; quite the opposite, in my
view.” He called for creative thought on “a
sustainable strategy for Iraq and for the region.”
Ignatius wrote on June 22 that after an exchange of
e-mails with a U.S. military commander, he suggested
the United States use the Kurdish “militias” in the
north and the Shiite in the south to help maintain
stability, and a “local force” in the Sunni areas,
“until a national army is ready.”
Thomas Friedman wrote in the June 15 New York Times,
“This is no time to give up — this is still winnable
— but it is time to ask: What is our strategy?”
“Maybe it is too late,” says Friedman, “but before we
give up on Iraq, why not actually try to do it right?
Double the American boots on the ground and redouble
the diplomatic effort to bring in those Sunnis who
want to be part of the process and fight to the death
those who don’t.”
Friedman admitted that nobody wants to hear about more
troops in Iraq, but “we are fooling ourselves” to
think that “a decent, normal, forward-looking Iraqi
politics or army” can emerge out of a totally insecure
environment where one could feel safe only with one’s
own tribe.
An article in the June 17 L.A. Times quoted Secretary
of State Condoleezza Rice, who pledged to explain the
administration’s objectives. “I would say this is not
going to be an American enterprise for the long term.”
On June 21, the Washington Post carried a column,
“There’s Progress in Iraq,” by the secretary-general
of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, who says he was
traveling to Brussels to join representatives of more
than 80 governments and institutions with “a loud and
clear message of support” for the political transition
in Iraq, that “we recognize how much progress has been
made in the face of daunting challenges,” and that as
the Iraq people continue on a “long and tough road
ahead,” the United Nations is “privileged and
determined to walk it with them.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published June 29, 2005