Assimilation is the key to America’s immigration problem, ending e pluribus chaos and putting “e pluribus unum” — “out of many, one” — on the track envisioned by America’s Founders.
In recent times, some have asserted a different take on diversity, changing “out of many, one” into “out of one, many.” America’s “melting pot,” that mix of peoples of different ethnicities from different places into American hybrids, was challenged by the mosaic “salad” concept of diverse peoples under the banner of “cultural pluralism.”
In the book, “Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity,” Harvard Professor Samuel P. Huntington is both criticized and praised for urging Americans to reclaim the “core values” that make them Americans.
Gunnar Myrdal’s 1944 popularization of the “core of the American Creed” included “the essential dignity of the individual human being … the fundamental equality of all men and … inalienable rights to freedom, justice, and a fair opportunity.”
Thomas Jefferson described the equality of men and their inalienable rights to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” in the Declaration of Independence in 1776.
To Huntington, America’s Founders, the English settlers, brought with them a distinct culture that included the English language, Protestant values, individualism, religious commitment and respect for law — values which were embraced by waves of immigrants who assimilated into America’s “Anglo-Protestant” culture.
But “powerful movements” in the 1960s challenged America as a national community of individuals sharing a common culture, history and creed, wrote Huntington; it presented her as “a conglomerate of different races, ethnicities, and subnational cultures” and “denounced the idea of Americanization as un-American.”
So, history textbooks were rewritten, the English language was downgraded, bilingual education and linguistic diversity were expanded, the rights of subgroups and racial preferences were advocated above the rights of the individual, which had been central to the American Creed.
Huntington wrote, “substantial elements of America’s elites” in academia, the media, business and the professions joined “governmental elites” to deconstruct America. Yet “in poll after poll and in several referenda,” Americans “remained deeply patriotic, nationalistic … and committed to their national culture, creed, and identity.” This has created a gap between America’s elite and the greater mass of the American people.
He reminds that between 1820 and 1924, many of the 34 million Europeans who came to America and stayed were partially assimilated; their children and grandchildren, “almost totally” assimilated. But between 1965 and 2000, 23 million new Latin American and Asian immigrants posed an issue of “immigration with or without assimilation,” eroding America’s national identity, which was challenged by bilingualism, multiculturalism, the downgrading of citizenship and the “denationalization” of American politics.
Huntington presented three models of immigrants: The “converts,” who believe in America, her principles and her culture and “yearn” to be Americans; the “sojourners,” who earn American wages and return home; and the “ampersands,” who can have “dual residences, dual attachments, dual loyalties, and often dual citizenship in America and their birth country.”
In the May 19 New York Times’ “The Day an Immigrant Refugee Can Say, ‘I’m an American’,” Helene Cooper, whose family migrated to America “in bits and pieces … fleeing coups, revolutions and civil wars” in Liberia, became a U.S. citizen in 1997. Her mom, who came in 1990, became an American only on May 17.
Cooper said her mom worked as “a home health aide. … It was a far cry from our well-off existence in Liberia. But who wouldn’t rather be poor in America than rich in a country where soldiers could enter your home, rape your children and murder your parents?”
Cooper watched her mom tear up as she sang “The Star-Spangled Banner,” insist on pushing her walker up to the dais to receive her naturalization certificate, “to be next to the (American) flag.”
In America’s dark hours of deep division among her people, there are many who want to become Americans.
Cooper wrote, “a green card isn’t enough. There is something about being able to say you’re American that can get in your gut.” Maybe it means “you, or your parents or grandparents, came from somewhere else. For all the national debate about immigration, this remains a country defined by the diversity of its people.”
The Founders believed “e pluribus unum” could be achieved in America.
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the University of Guam, where he taught political science for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published May 31, 2006