The so-called “Bush doctrine” was formulated after the
Sept. 11 attacks that took place on U.S. soil.
Reiterated in the March 2006 National Security
Strategy document, the doctrine has been repeated by
President George W. Bush and senior officials: The
United States “is at war.” It doesn’t deal with
terrorists and doesn’t distinguish between terrorists
and countries that harbor them. It will fight “enemies
abroad” rather than waiting for them to come fight on
U.S. soil. It will “support democratic movements and
institutions” everywhere with the ultimate goal of
“ending tyranny in our world.”
It was a “revolutionary” foreign policy with global
intent that was endorsed enthusiastically by those who
took the doctrine seriously, and caused anxiety among
those who saw it as America’s entry into a quagmire
that could sink the country.
Today, some people have argued that Bush’s
“revolution” is more rhetoric than real, as U.S.
foreign policy courses have been shifting. While
Bush’s political opponents continue to oppose his
leadership, his political proponents are divided, some
are unhappy with the policy course and see Bush
betraying the “doctrine.”
In “Whither the Bush Doctrine?” in the July 19
National Review Online, former federal prosecutor and
currently senior fellow at the Foundation for the
Defense of Democracies, Andrew C. McCarthy, writes
about nuclear negotiations with Iran, with “All
carrot, no stick … and no mention of terror” and
sees the U.S.-China-Russia-Britain-France-Germany
proposal to Iran as “crushing for those who took the
Bush Doctrine seriously.”
McCarthy’s isn’t a lone voice of disappointment with
Bush.
A Brookings Institution foreign policy studies senior
fellow, Philip H. Gordon, co-author of the book
“Allies at War: America, Europe, and the Crisis Over
Iraq,” posited in the July-August Foreign Affairs “The
End of the Bush Revolution” — that Bush and senior
aides still talk tough about a doctrine but cannot
sustain it.
The United States will “act boldly in freedom’s cause”
and “never surrender to evil,” Bush declared in his
2006 State of the Union address. Has it, really?
Gordon sees the Bush administration’s foreign policy
“already on a different trajectory than it was in
Bush’s first term” and that Bush can no longer ignore
the budgetary, political and diplomatic realities.
Gordon asserted “Bush has already begun” to “put U.S.
foreign policy back on a more sustainable course.”
To Gordon, the Bush doctrine was an “accidental
revolution” and is over. He dismissed a common notion
that the “Bush team was hawkish and interventionist”
from the start: “If anything,” the Bush team “leaned
toward the realist view that the United States should
avoid meddling in the domestic affairs of other
nations.”
This “cautious realism” ended with the invasion of
Iraq because of the “sudden sense of vulnerability”
caused by Sept. 11, which persuaded Americans to do
something, and a “sense of unprecedented power” that
convinced Americans that they could. Thus began an
idealistic trip to “eliminate threats” such as Saddam
Hussein and to spread democracy worldwide regardless
of what anyone may think.
But when Bush’s revolution met reality, “everything
has not turned out as planned.” From an inherited
annual budgetary surplus of $200 billion to an annual
deficit of $400 billion, with a national debt climbing
to $8 trillion and rising, to bogging down in Iraq,
poor handling of the Hurricane Katrina aftermath and
the Dubai Ports World controversy, among others,
Bush’s approval rating has fallen to under 35 percent.
With Bush’s second term, a “modified approach” to
foreign policy “was immediately apparent in the new
tone and style.” Neo-conservatives such as Paul
Wolfowitz, Douglas Feith and John Bolton have left the
hall of power; “pragmatists” such as Robert Zoellick,
Nicholas Burns and Christopher Hill have come in.
Policies have shifted regarding Europe, Iran, North
Korea, foreign aid and climate change, among others.
The “war” on terror is a “generational” struggle that
requires winning “global hearts, minds and sympathy.”
“The reversal of the Bush revolution is a good thing,”
Gordon wrote, but warned of the “risk of relapse.”
Another major terrorist attack on U.S. soil, “which
remains possible,” or Iran’s provocation, could push
Bush back to the old track.
While Gordon thinks “global realities and resource
constraints” will continue to force Bush “toward
pragmatism, modesty and cooperation with allies,”
should a relapse occur, “brace yourself — because
there is no reason to believe that round two of the
Bush revolution would be more successful than round
one.”
A. Gaffar Peang-Meth, Ph.D., is retired from the
University of Guam, where he taught political science
for 13 years. Write him at peangmeth@yahoo.com.
Originally published August 2, 2006